Skip to main content
. 2006 Jan 25;2006(1):CD002982. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD002982.pub3
Study Reason for exclusion
Ago 1976 CCT of teaching patients about the mind‐body relationship
Allen 1995 RCT of a self‐management programme
Anon 1968 RCT of hypnosis in adults and children. Unable to separate data
Bailey 1990 RCT of a self‐management programme. Intervention was mainly education with a small element of counselling
Barendregt 1957 CCT of group psychotherapy
Ben‐Zvi 1982 Before and after study of hypnosis
Bosley 1995 Abstract only ‐ unclear if RCT or CCT
Boulet 1995 CCT of an education only programme
Cambach 1997 RCT of pulmonary rehabilitation including asthma and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) patients
Ciurluini 1993 CCT of psychotherapy techniques
Clark 1997 Review of self‐management education programmes
Coen 1996 RCT of relaxation. Study includes adults and children. Unable to separate data
Conte 1981 Review of psychotherapy for medically ill patients
Cox 1991 CCT of rehabilitation. Study includes asthma and COPD patients. Unable to separate data
De Vries 2004 Not randomised ‐ patients allocated to treatment on an alternate basis.
Deter 1983a Cost effectiveness study based on data of included study (Deter 1983)
Devine 1996 Meta‐analysis of psychoeducational care
Erskine‐Milliss 1987 Two studies of biofeedback in adults and children (before and after study)
Fernandes 2006 RCT evaluating the effect of multi‐disciplinary education and multi‐ family psychotherapy.
Franco 1982 CCT of hypnosis
Fujii 1997 Case study of step‐down management of asthma
Gashynova 2005 RCT evaluating the influence of psychological intervention. No details of the psychological rehabilitation content provided (author contact attempted).
Ghosh 1998 RCT of self‐management without psychotherapy in adults and children
Groen 1960 Clinical study, not controlled or randomised
Grover 2002 CCT of Cognitive Behavioural Therapy
Hackman 2000 Review of hypnosis in adults and children with asthma
Haire‐Joshu 1993 Survey, focus groups and interview to assess patients' attitudes according to clinical setting
Hajjar 1999 Review of behavioural interventions in asthma
Harding 1982 CCT Of biofeedback training
Hashizume 1996 Psychosomatic therapies in a before and after study
Hirokawa 1992 CCT of biofeedback apparatus
Huntley 2002 Review of relaxation therapies for asthma
Jonckheere 1997 Review of psychosomatic issues in a range of diseases
Kang 1993 Before and after study of the impact of psychological factors in adolescents.
Kaptein 1987 Review (COPD)
Kern‐Buell 2000 Adults and children included in RCT on relaxation
Khateeb 1995 Meta‐analysis of psychotherapy
Klingelhofer 1988 Review of asthma self‐management programmes
Kolbe 1996 Knowledge of self‐management outcome measure validity study
Kotses 1991 CCT of self‐management without psychotherapy
Kotses 1995 RCT of self‐management without psychotherapy
Kotses 1996 RCT of self‐management, primarily education although some received a relaxation tape
Lahdensuo 1996 RCT of a self‐management programme
Laidlaw 1994 Before and after study of hypnosis
Langewitz 2005 RCT of self‐hypnosis on hay fever symptoms. Participants had mild asthma. Outcome measures related to hay fever symptoms only.
Lehrer 1986 CCT of relaxation and biofeedback
Lehrer 1992 Review of psychological approaches in asthma
Lehrer 1993 Review of the relationship between emotion and asthma
Lehrer 1997a Analysis of data from 1994 study (included) to study the physiological relationship between pulmonary function and autonomic control of the heart.
Lehrer 2003 Evaluation of biofeedback with healthy adults
Lehrer 2006 Additional analysis from a previously published study evaluationg the effects of biofeedback (See included studies Lehrer 2004).
Levendel 1980 Narrative review of the biofeedback method
Lewith 1996 Review of complementary therapies in asthma
Linden 1994 Review of autogenic training in a range of diseases
Loew 1996 Before and after study of functional relaxation
Loew 2001 Crossover study.
Maes 1988 CCT of an education and behaviour modification intervention
Matts 1973 Review of the treatment of bronchospasm (including psychological)
Moore 1965 CCT of behavioural therapy. Adults and children included in study
Murphy 1989 CCT of hypnotic susceptibility and relaxation
Mussell 1988 Crossover study.
Nagata 1995 Before and after study of a psychosomatic treatment
Negley‐Parker 1986 Case report of hypnotherapy of families of children with chronic illness
Nickel 2005 RCT of relaxation therapy in adolescent patients. Author unable to separate data to include only participants 16 years or older.
Nickel 2006 RCT evaluating relaxation therapy for pregnant women with asthma.
Nowobilski 2005 RCT of music therapy ‐ no psychological input.
Peper 1992 CCT of behavioural and desensitization programme using biofeedback
Richter 1982 Review of psychosomatic aspects of asthma
Richter 1987 Review of behavioural therapy and relaxation
Ringsberg 1990 RCT of self‐management without psychotherapy
Ritz 2001 Systematic review of relaxation therapies for asthma
Sachs 1993 CCT of relaxation training
Sauer 1978 CCT of autogenic training
Schaeffer 1975 CCT of self‐training
Sclare 1957 CCT of group therapy
Smith 2005 RCT of mostly educational intervention
Snyder 1987 RCT of self‐management without psychotherapy
Song 2005 Quasi‐experiemental study (allocation based on hospital number) evaluating relaxation, breathing exercises and individual psychological intervention.
Spiess 1988 RCT of education intervention (non‐randomised sub group received relaxation therapy)
Stepans 2000 RCT of patients with asthma and COPD. Unable to separate data.
Steptoe 1981 CCT of biofeedback, non asthmatic volunteers included
Stout 1997 RCT of breathing retraining only
Stuhr 1996 Review of psychosomatic and psychotherapy research
Vedanthan 1998 RCT of yoga
Vickers 1997 Survey and review of complementary therapies
Wilson 1975 Cross‐over study of transcendental meditation
Wilson 1993 RCT of self‐management without psychotherapy
Zukiwski 2002 RCT of two different forms of relaxation (no control group).