Table 5.
Study (year) | Type of study | Duration of study | No. of patients (implants) | Site of operation | Groups T: Test group C: Control group | Outcome (mean±SD) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Isler S et al (2018) | RCT | 12 months | 52 (52) | Not specified | T=CGF | T=1.63±1.00 mm |
C=Collagen membrane (Bio Guide) | C=1.98±0.75 mm P=0.154 (NS) |
|||||
Kim J et al (2014) | Retrospective study | 23.8 weeks | 10 (16) | Maxillary posterior | T=CGF | T=8.236±2.88 mm, varying from 4.2-12.7 mm. P<0.05 (S) |
No control group | ||||||
S Manoj et al (2018) | Prospective study | 6 months | 10 (10) | Mandibular posterior | T=CGF | T=2.7 mm (mesial), 4.26 mm (distal), 2.3 mm (buccal) and 1.52 mm (lingual), P<0.05 (S) |
No control group | ||||||
Shetty M et al (2018) | Prospective study | 6 months | 20 | Maxillary posterior | T: CGF | T=1.932±2.22 (mesial), |
C: Without CGF | 2.621±1.76 (distal), 3.864±1.51 (palatal), 4.417±2.01 (buccal) | |||||
Yang L et al (2014) | Prospective study | 12 months | 20 (20) | Maxillary posterior | T=CGF C=Bio-oss |
T=0.85±0.25mm C=0.35±0.25mm. P<0.05 (S) |
Chen Y et al (2016) | Retrospective study | 2 years with follow up at 19.88 months | 16 (25) | Maxillary posterior | T=CGF | T=9.21±0.66 mm. |
No control group | P<0.05 (S) |