Skip to main content
. 2019 Sep 12;17(9):e05780. doi: 10.2903/j.efsa.2019.5780

Table 1.

Literature search flow

  Contractor search Shiny R quality check in contractor excluded Hand search in contractor excluded Complementary search by EFSA Upgrade contractor search by EFSA Upgrade complementary search by EFSA Hand search by EFSA TOTAL Developmental readiness
Initial hits 7,280 1,037 n/a 4,681 4,249 + 661b 1,877 + 446b n/a 19,194a 1,412
Included full‐text screening step 1 352 107 n/a 477 271 + 32b 115 + 22b n/a 1,376 84

Included in full‐text screening

step 2

162 56 29 102 140 + 0b 21 + 0b 87 597 27
Duplicates n/a −2 n/a −50 −41 −2 n/a −95 n/a
Excluded full‐text screening step 2 (without duplicates) −44 −24 −10 −26 −65 −12 −40 −221 −12
Included papers on prospective studies 111 14 7 20 22 3 24 201

15 +

8 hand search +

2 from SR

Included papers on retrospective studies 7 18 12 6 12 4 23 82 n/a

n/a: not applicable; SR: systematic review.

a

Excludes the 1,037 references re‐screened using Shiny R;

b

number of publications retrieved in the update of the search (limited to RCTs) performed during the time period when the draft Scientific Opinion was subjected to public consultation.