Skip to main content
. 2017 Apr 20;15(4):e04773. doi: 10.2903/j.efsa.2017.4773

Table 4.

Advantages and disadvantages of traps types for different vector species

Vector Trap Advantages Disadvantages
Ticks Direct collection
  • Species of relevance are collected on animals. There is no bias due to trapping

  • Specimens can be analysed for virus detection

  • Time and manpower‐consuming

  • Difficult for long term sampling

Culicoides Light trap
  • Ideal for long term studies

  • Several farms can be sampled at the same time with little manpower

  • Specimens can be analysed for virus detection

  • Initial investment on equipment

  • Some bias on collected species may occur due to the type of trap

Mosquitoes Light trap and/or CO2 trap
  • Ideal for long‐term studies

  • Several farms can be sampled at the same time with little manpower

  • Specimens can be analysed for virus detection

  • Initial investment on equipment

  • Some bias on collected species may occur due to the type of trap

  • It requires a constant source of CO2

  • Diurnal mosquitoes require different types of traps

Stable fly Various glue traps
  • Easy‐to‐operate, cheap and efficient

  • Flies stay on traps

  • The identification of species may be difficult

  • Extraction of DNA for virus detection is almost impossible

Horn fly Sweeping net
  • Probably the best method for trapping adults

  • Insects can be kept alive and used further for virus detection

  • Insects are actually feeding on the host

  • Other feeding insects can be trapped as well

  • Sweeping may disperse the flies and low numbers may be obtained

  • Can only be done when animals are restrained as most animals are not tamed

  • It is time‐consuming and manpower is required

Tabanids Liquid trap
  • Efficient, easy‐to‐operate and cheap

  • Insects can be used later

  • Do not reflect actual feeding flies, but water‐seeking flies

Canopy trap
  • Efficient for host seeking flies

  • Insects can be used later

  • Commercial traps can be expensive and may require baits for trapping improvement

L‐shape sticky trap
  • Efficient trap

  • It collects both host‐seeking and water‐seeking vectors

  • Insects cannot be used for further analysis

Flies on host Counting
  • This method reflects the actual feeding vectors

  • It does not require a specific setting

  • This method will not yield flies for further testing

  • It requires trained personnel to identify the flies from distance

Vacuum‐based trap
  • This method reflects the actual feeding vectors

  • It yields a large number of flies

  • Expensive

  • Requires manpower