Skip to main content
. 2020 Feb 11;18:19. doi: 10.1186/s12916-019-1489-0

Table 3.

Methods of new TB diagnosis immediately before ART and in the first 6 months of ART in the SOC, EC, and EC+X phases of XPRES

SOC phase EC phase EC+X phase
n % n % n %
Pulmonary TB
 Microbiologically confirmed pulmonary TB (smear microscopy in SOC and EC, Xpert during EC+X) 22 18 23 34 113 57
 Microbiologically confirmed pulmonary TB through culturea (missing or negative smear and Xpert) 0 0 12 18 16 8
 Clinical diagnosis of pulmonary TB with negative sputum test (negative smear, Xpert, or culture documented) 6b 5 6d 9 17f 9
 Clinical diagnosis of pulmonary TB with no documented sputum test result 95c 77 27e 40 52g 26
Sub-total pulmonary TB 123 100 68 100 198 100
All TB
 Pulmonary TB total 123 95 68 79 198 81
 Extra-pulmonary TB total 6 5 18 21 46 19
Total 129 100 86 100 244 100

Abbreviations: SOC standard of care, EC enhanced care, EC+X enhanced care plus Xpert, TB tuberculosis, XPRES Xpert Package Rollout Evaluation using a Stepped-wedge design

aTo meet other study objectives related to estimation of diagnostic accuracy of the smear microscopy-based and Xpert-based TB diagnostic algorithms, one spot sputum and the morning sputum were sent to the National TB Reference Laboratory (NTRL) for liquid culture in mycobacteria growth indicator tubes (MGIT). The liquid culture results were also returned to the clinics, although average turnaround times exceeding 49 days were expected per existing standard of care

b5 (83%) of 6 had documentation that x-ray findings were suggestive of pulmonary TB

c13 (14%) of 95 had documentation that x-ray findings were suggestive of pulmonary TB

d3 (50%) of 6 had documentation that x-ray findings were suggestive of pulmonary TB

e16 (59%) of 27 had documentation that x-ray findings were suggestive of pulmonary TB

f8 (47%) of 17 had documentation that x-ray findings were suggestive of pulmonary TB

g20 (38%) of 52 had documentation that x-ray findings were suggestive of pulmonary TB