Table 1.
Tools for studying membrane receptor glycosylation | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|
Method | Working principle | Applications | Limitations | References |
Quantitative and qualitive measurement of receptor glycosylation | ||||
SDS-PAGE and glycan-cleaving enzymes | Separating glycoforms by differences in molecular weight, using cell lysates treated with or without glycan-cleaving enzymes. | Quick and easy way to observe different glycoforms and roughly assess localization: membrane vs. cytosol. | No detailed information on glycan structure. Glycoforms with small or no differences in molecular weight cannot be separated. |
Freeze and Kranz, 2010 |
Lectin blot | Separating glycoforms by differences in molecular weight and staining with glycan binding lectins. | Analyze different glycoforms in cell lysates and provides insights regarding glycan composition. | Low binding affinity and specificity of lectins. No detailed information on glycan structure. | Cao et al., 2013 |
Chemoenzymatic labeling | Building a monosaccharide analog into the glycan chain to introduce a chemical modification compatible with click chemistry reactions. | Specific glycan structures can be labeled on live cells or cell lysates. | No detailed information on glycan structure or site occupancy. Labeling is not specific for the protein of interest. | Lopez Aguilar et al., 2017 |
Lectin and antibody labeling | Visualizing specific glycan structures by lectin or antibody staining. | Labeling specific glycan structures for microscopy or flow cytometry. | Low binding affinity and specificity of lectins. Labeling is not specific for the protein of interest. | Tommasone et al., 2019 |
In situ proximity ligation assay | Antibodies conjugated to oligonucleotides can only ligate and be visualized when the antibody targets are in close proximity. | Provides information on the location of glycoforms within the cell and on the cell membrane. | No detailed information on glycan structure. Distance between the detected entities can be up to 40 nm, sometimes complicating data interpretation. |
Soderberg et al., 2006 |
Glycomics | Analyzing glycan structure with mass spectrometry-based techniques. | Provides detailed structural information on glycans released from their protein backbone. | No information on the location of the glycosylation site within the protein. | Lauc and Wuhrer, 2017 |
Glycoproteomics | Analyzing glycopeptides with mass spectrometry-based techniques. | Provides information on the location of the glycosylation site and the glycan structure as well as micro- and macro-heterogeneity. | Glycan fine structures cannot be dissected when using large scale glycopeptide analysis. Complicated data analysis creating many false positive identifications. |
Lauc and Wuhrer, 2017; Yang et al., 2017; Narimatsu H. et al., 2018 |
FRET-based labeling of glycoproteins | Energy transfer from a donor fluorophore to an acceptor fluorophore can only occur when the antibody targets are in close proximity. | Provides information on the cellular location of glycoforms. | No detailed information on glycan structure and site-occupancy. | Lin et al., 2014 |
Strategies for manipulation of membrane receptor glycosylation | ||||
Metabolic inhibitors | Different strategies, examples are sugar analogs, oligosaccharyltransferase inhibitors or inhibitors of glycosyltransferases. | Inhibition of the glycosylation pathway resulting in loss, truncation or modification of glycans. | Unwanted side-effects. Effect not specific for protein of interest. | Wojtowicz et al., 2012 |
Knockdown or knockout of glycosyltransferases | RNA interference or CRISPR-Cas9 genome editing. | Inhibition of the glycosylation pathway resulting in loss, truncation or modification of glycans. | Need for easy-to-transfect cell-line. Effect not specific for protein of interest. | Stolfa et al., 2016; Narimatsu Y. et al., 2018 |
Site-directed mutagenesis | Changing the glycosylation consensus sequence by changing the amino acid sequence of the protein and therefore removing the glycosylation site. | Removing one or multiple glycan chains from a specific protein. | Need for easy-to-transfect cell-line. Amino-acid substitution can affect other protein properties besides glycan presence. Modification of glycans is not possible. | Barbosa et al., 1987; Bordo and Argos, 1991; Weber et al., 2004 |