Table 2.
Average fold changes for gene classes of untreated WW over treated WW for H, U and M WW (p values ≤ 0.03) ± Standard Deviation. * = significantly lower; + = significantly higher. Significant differences were calculated by comparing the normalized cumulative abundance values of individual gene classes for all samples belonging to each sample group using the non-parametric Mann-Whitney test. Fold changes were calculated for individually paired samples for each gene class/sample group. Average fold change ± Standard Deviation are depicted in the table for comparison. NA indicates that gene classes were undetectable in either one or both of the sample groups.
Gene classes conferring resistance to: | Fold change H untreated WW/H treated WW | Fold change U untreated WW/U treated WW | Fold change M untreated WW/M treated WW |
---|---|---|---|
chloramphenicol | 34 (±47)* | 5 (±12)* | 16 (±27)* |
aminoglycosides | 15 (±14)* | 3 (±5) * | 7 (±10)* |
bacitracin | 12 (±30)* | 1 (±2) | 1 (±1) |
beta-lactams | 30 (±42) * | 4 (±14) | 10 (±21) |
erythromycin (macrolides) | 48 (±68)* | 27 (±55)* | 23 (+17)* |
(multi-drug) efflux | 29 (±43)* | 9 (±27)* | 13 (±17)* |
quinolones | 78 (±123)* | 3 (±5) | 19 (±29)* |
heavy metals | 15 (±32) * | 3 (±3) | 2 (±2) |
quaternary ammonium compounds(QACs) | 5 (±5) * | 1 (±2) | 2 (±2) |
vancomycin | NA (undetectable in all but one sample for treated HWW) | NA (undetectable in all but one sample for treated UWW) | NA (undetectable in all samples for treated MWW) |
tetracycline | 51 (±77)* | 13 (±40)* | 6 (±5) |
polymixin | 29 (±52)* | 5 (±12) * | 7 (±7)* |
sulphonamides | 5 (±6)* | 1 (±1)+ | 2 (±1) |
Streptogramin | 17 (±43)* | 43 (±77)* | 41 (±20)* |
methicillin | NA (undetectable in all treated HWW samples) | NA (undetectable in all treated UWW samples) | NA (undetectable in all but one treated MWW sample) |
trimethoprim | 66 (±101)* | 9 (±28)* | 6 (±7)* |
Gene classes grouped according to function: | |||
transposase genes (MGEs) | 5 (±5)* | 6 (±7)* | 5 (±3)* |
integron integrase genes | 7 (±6)* | 1 (±1) | 3 (±4)* |