Table 2.
Type | Model (Trigger, Onset of Pathology) |
Pros/Cons | Pathological Findings | Behavioral Assay (Pain Response Onset) |
Findings | Molecular Pathogenesis Identified |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Induced (onset after first immunization) |
CIA (CII/adjuvant) |
Most common induced model, RA-like pathogenesis. Restricted strains in mice, severe progressive disease. |
-Adaptive immune system activation against endogenous joint epitopes. -Inflammation -Immune cell infiltration -Joint destruction and synovial hyperplasia |
von Frey (30 d), rotarod (5 d), locomotion (25 d), tail flick (1 wk), Hargreaves (24 d) | Pain response is induced rapidly after induction. Pain response increases in early phase and persists. Most representative methods: von Frey and Hargreaves |
Anti-Cat S and FKN attenuate pain in CIA. Gabapentin and buprenorphine attenuate pain in CAIA. Knockout of TLR-4 inhibits pain in K/BxN. |
CAIA (Anti-CII Ab) |
Efficient and robust to study the effector phase of RA, diverse susceptible strains. Does not involve full spectrum of immune activation. |
-Inflammation -Immune cell infiltration -Joint destruction |
von Frey (6 d), hot plate (15 d), locomotion (5 d) | |||
K/BxN (Serum/Anti-GPI Ab) |
von Frey (2 d), Hargreaves (3 d), locomotion (3 d) | |||||
AIA (mBSA/adjuvant) |
Local RA-like pathogenesis, localized inflammation. Damage to cartilage less severe than in RA. |
-Adaptive immune system activation against exogenous epitopes -Inflammation -Immune cell infiltration -Joint destruction and synovial hyperplasia |
von Frey (22 d), Hargreaves (7 d), gait (15 d), incapacitance (17 d) | Pain response is induced rapidly after induction. Pain response increases in early phase and restores in late phase. Most representative methods: von Frey and incapacitance |
Anti-IL-17 alleviates pain in AIA. Increase of IL-1RI and pCREB in AIA. |
|
Spontaneous | TNF-Tg (hTNF overexpression) |
Useful for studies in effect of excess TNF in RA. Only been identified in mice, does not involve full spectrum of immune activation. |
-Inflammation -Immune cell infiltration -Joint destruction and synovial hyperplasia -Pannus formation |
von Frey (6 wk), tail flick (10 wk), Hargreaves (6 wk) |
Pain response increases in early phase and persists. Most representative methods: von Frey and Hargreaves |
Increase of the nociceptive brain activity in TNF-Tg mice. |
IL-1RA−/− (Genetic deficiency of 1L-1Ra) |
Useful for studies in effect of IL-1 signaling in RA. Only been identified in mice. |
No behavioral data available to date. |
CIA, collagen-induced arthritis; CAIA, collagen antibody-induced arthritis; AIA, antigen-induced arthritis; TNF-Tg, tumor necrosis factor transgene; IL-1RA–/–, interleukin-1 receptor antagonist knockout; CII, collagen type II; Ab, antibody; mBSA, methylated bovine serum albumin; GPI, glucose-6-phosphateisomerase; hTNF, human tumor necrosis factor; RA, rheumatoid arthritis; d, day; wk, week(s); Cat S, cathepsin S; FKN, fractalkine; TLR-4, toll-like receptor 4; IL-1RI, interleukin-1 receptor type I; pCREB, phospho-CREB.