Table 3.
Effects of the sodium bicarbonate intervention on the primary (urinary TGF-β1) and secondary outcomes (urinary fibronectin, KIM-1, NGAL, and albumin)
Outcome | Primary Outcome | Secondary Outcomes | ||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
TGF-β1/Cr | Fibronectin/Cr | KIM-1/Cr | NGAL/Cr | Albumin/Cr | ||||||
Sodium Bicarbonate | Placebo | Sodium Bicarbonate | Placebo | Sodium Bicarbonate | Placebo | Sodium Bicarbonate | Placebo | Sodium Bicarbonate | Placebo | |
Within-group Δ from baseline | ||||||||||
At mo 3 | 2% (−18% to 27%) | −11% (−28% to 10%) | 6% (−19% to 37%) | 3% (−20% to 32%) | −7% (−36% to 36%) | −13% (−40% to 25%) | −35% (−59% to 2%) | 2% (−34% to 58%) | 22% (−2 to 52) | 9% (−12% to 36%) |
At mo 6 | 13% (−6% to 36%) | 3% (−15% to 24%) | 12% (−9% to 38%) | −1% (−20% to 23%) | −16% (−38% to 14%) | 12% (−18% to 52%) | −21% (−46% to 16%) | 10% (−26% to 64%) | 9% (−19% to 46%) | 19% (−12% to 60%) |
Over mo 3 and 6 | 8% (−10% to 28%) | −4% (−19% to 13%) | 9% (−9% to 31%) | 1% (−16% to 21%) | −11% (−33% to 17%) | −2% (−25% to 29%) | −29% (−49% to 0%) | 6% (−24% to 48%) | 21% (−3% to 51%) | 12% (−11% to 40%) |
Sodium Bicarbonate versus Placebo | Sodium Bicarbonate versus Placebo | Sodium Bicarbonate versus Placebo | Sodium Bicarbonate versus Placebo | Sodium Bicarbonate versus Placebo | ||||||
Difference in change from baseline | ||||||||||
At mo 3 | 15% (−13% to 53%) | 3% (−27% to 45%) | 7% (−36% to 81%) | −36% (−65% to 16%) | 12% (−18% to 52%) | |||||
At mo 6 | 10% (−14% to 41%) | 13% (−16% to 51%) | −25% (−50% to 13%) | −28% (−58% to 22%) | −9% (−40% to 38%) | |||||
Over mo 3 and 6 | 13% (−10% to 40%) | 8% (−15% to 37%) | −10% (−38% to 31%) | −33% (−56% to 4%) | 1% (−25% to 36%) |
Data are shown as geometric mean percentage change (95% confidence intervals). Positive values for difference in change indicate that the change was greater in the sodium bicarbonate group. Cr, creatinine; KIM-1, kidney injury molecule-1; NGAL, neutrophil gelatinase-associated lipocalin.