Table 2:
Medication | Mechanism of Action | Available Evidence in Adults | Available Evidence in Children |
---|---|---|---|
Erythromycin | Motilin receptor agonist | - SR* (2003)[59] - SA* (1999)[58] - DB*, PC*, XO* – improved antroduodenal motor activity (1997)[55] - RC*, DB, PC – accelerated gastric emptying (1995)[56] - OL* (1994)[60] - OL (1994)[61] - OL (1993)[63] - RC, DB, XO with metoclopramide – improved symptoms, more pronounced with erythromycin (1993)[62] - RC, DB, PC, XO – accelerated gastric emptying (1990)[57] |
- Re (2012)[14] - SR (in neonates) (2005)[73] - RC, DB, PC – no difference (2003)[70] - RC, DB, PC – no difference (2003)[71] - RC, DB, vs metoclopramide study (2001)[64] - RC, DB, PC – accelerated gastric emptying (2001)[68] - P, RC, DB, PC – improved enteral feeding (2001)[69] - RC, DB, PC – improved gastric emptying (2001)[72] - RC, DB, PC – no difference (2000)[66] - RC, DB – no difference (1998)[67] |
Metoclopramide | Dopamine D2 receptor antagonist, serotonin 5-HT4 agonist | - MA*, SR (2019)[80] - RC, DB, PC – reduction in GP symptoms in women but not men (2015)[82] - RC, DB, vs domperidone – equally effective but more pronounced CNS side effects with metoclopramide (1999)[81] - RC, DB, XO with erythromycin – improved symptoms, more pronounced with erythromycin (1993)[62] - RC, DB, PC XO – improved symptoms (1985)[79] - OL (1984)[121] - RC, PC – improved symptoms, accelerated gastric emptying (1983)[78] - RC, DB, PC, XO – improved symptoms and vomiting, acceleration of gastric emptying (1982)[76] - RC, DB, PC – improved symptoms (1979)[77] - OL (1977)[122] |
- Re (2015)[75] - Re (2012) [14] - RC, DB, PC – accelerated gastric emptying in infants with regurgitation and infants with GP following abdominal surgery, no change in infants with GP related to prematurity (1988)[83] |
Domperidone | Dopamine D2 receptor antagonist but with lower central side effects when compared to metoclopramide | - MA, SR (2019)[80] - RC, PC, vs metoclopramide – equally effective but more pronounced CNS side effects with metoclopramide (1999)[81] - RC, PC, withdrawal study – improved symptoms (1998)[90] - OL (1997)[86] - Re(1990)[87] - OL (1989)[88] - RC, PC, XO – improved symptoms (1989)[91] - OL (1985)[89] - OL (1985)[85] - RC, PC, XO – accelerated gastric emptying (1983)[92] - RC, PC, XO- no difference (1981)[93] |
- Re (2012)[14] - RC, PC, XO (2010)[95] - RC, PC vs cisapride – domperidone superior to cisapride in improving symptoms and accelerating gastric emptying (2002) [94] |
Cisapride | Serotonin 5HT4 agonist, serotonin 5-HT3 antagonist | - MA, SR (2019)[80] - RC, PC – accelerated gastric emptying (2002)[100] - RC, DB, PC, XO – no difference (1999)[101] - RC, DB, PC, XO – no difference (1999)[102] - RC, DB, PC – accelerated gastric emptying but no improvement in symptoms (1993)[104] - DB, PC – accelerated gastric emptying but no improvement in symptoms (1989)[123] - RC, DB, XO – accelerated gastric emptying but no improvement in symptoms (1987)[103] - RC, vs metoclopramide, PC – accelerated gastric emptying with both, significant with cisapride (1987)[98] - DB, PC, XO – no difference (1987)[99] |
- RC, PC, vs cisapride – domperidone superior to cisapride in improving symptoms and accelerating gastric emptying (2002) [94] - RC, PC – improved feeds only in extremely low birth weight infants, but significant QTc prolongation (2005)[106] - RC, PC, XO – no difference (2001)[107] - RC, DB, PC – no difference (2000)[105] - RC, DB, PC – no difference (2000)[108] - RC, DB, PC – delayed gastric emptying (1999)[110] - RC, DB, PC – no difference (1998)[109] |
Botulinum Toxin | Decreases pylorus muscle contractility and acetylcholine release | - Re, OL (2014)[124] - Re, OL (2009)[117] - RC, DB – no difference (2008)[115] - RC, DB, XO – no difference (2007)[116] - Re, OL (2005)[125] - P, OL (2002)[114] - P, OL (2002)[113] |
- Re, OL (2012)[112] |
Re= Retrospective, R= Randomized controlled, OL= open label, P= prospective, DB= double-blind, XO= crossover, PC= placebo-controlled, SR= systematic review, SA= systematic analysis, MA= meta-analysis