Skip to main content
. 2019 Sep 19;57(2):775–786. doi: 10.1007/s13197-019-04110-z

Table 1.

Analysis of variance for the CCD models for sequential extraction and coefficients for the predictive models of the inulin and protein extraction/co-extraction yields. ANOVA was determined with a 95% confidence level

S1a S2a
Protein extraction Inulin extraction Inulin extraction
Protein yield Inulin co-extraction yield Inulin yield Inulin yield Protein co-extraction yield
Source D.f.b Co-efficient Sum of squares P-value Co-efficient Sum of squares P-value Co-efficient Sum of squares P-value Co-efficient Sum of squares P-value Co-efficient Sum of squares P-value
Linear
Temp (T) 1 0.01 31.14 0.019 0.35 4.24 0.127 4.44 50.96 0.009 5.11 63.25 0.004 5.35 132.41 0.005
pH (P) 1 10.34 16.51 0.051 − 2 6.67 0.086 3.65 25.08 0.03 3.25 33.95 0.014 − 24 2.38 0.51
Quadratic
T2 1 0. 9 3.56 0.271 − 0.002 22.35 0.014 − 0.33 63.66 0.006 − 0.04 87.05 0.002 0.05 172.09 0.003
P2 1 − 0.94 98.64 0.002 − 0.33 11.89 0.039 3.99 12.66 0.077 4.05 7.315 0.13 0.599 40.03 0.04
Interaction
TP 1 − 0.004 0.19 0.78 − 0.02 2.89 0.21 0.04 0.125 0.82 0.1 1 0.517 − 0.96 92.16 0.01
Regression 1 150.06 0.001 48.59 0.01 151.3 0.01 439.06 0.01 192.39 0.01
Residual error 1 32.78 11.81 24.4 20.98 32.79
Lack of fit 3 24.05 0.12 6.61 0.3 16.32 0.208 27.97 0.084 24.05 0.09
Pure error 4 8.73 5.21 9.06 7.96 8.73
Model 12 189.59 65.33 171.28 236.56 440.7
R2 0.82 0.81 0.85 0.95 0.82
Adjusted R2 0.7 0.69 0.74 0.92 0.7

aS1 and S2 is scenario 1 (protein extraction and inulin extraction first and second, respectively) and scenario 2 (inulin extraction first) for the sequential extraction, respectively

bd.f. is the degrees of freedom