Table 1.
Characteristics of included studies.
Authors, year | Location | Participants | Number | Experimental group | Control group | Follow-up | Outcome measures | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Types of treatment | Duration (min) | Frequency | ||||||||
Zhang Y., 2008 | China | Women with T2DM | E: 10; C: 10 | Tai Chi | 60 min | Five times weekly | Nonexercise | 14 weeks | (1)FBG (2)TC, HDL-C, LDL-C, TG |
|
Chen S. C., 2010 | Taiwan (China) | Patients with T2DM | E: 56; C: 48 | Tai Chi | 60 min | Three times weekly | Other active exercises (aerobic exercise plus home-based exercise) | 12 weeks | (1)HbA1c, FBG | |
Lam P., 2008 | Australia | Adults with T2DM | E: 28; C: 25 | Tai Chi | 60 min | Two classes weekly | Nonexercise | 24 weeks | (1)HbA1c (2)TC, TG |
|
Youngwanichsetha S., 2013 | Thailand | Women with T2DM | E:32; CG:32 | Tai Chi | 50 min | Three times weekly | Nonexercise | 12 weeks | (1)HbA1c, FBG (2) BMI |
|
ORR R., 2006 | Australia | Older adults with T2DM | E: 17; C: 18 | Tai Chi | 60 min | Twice weekly | Other active exercises (sham exercise, e.g., seated calisthenics and stretching) | 16 weeks | (1) FBG | |
Xiao C. M., 2015 | China | Older adults with DM | E: 16; C: 16 | Tai Chi | 1 to 2 hours | Three sessions per week | Nonexercise | 12 weeks | (1)HbA1c | |
Sreedevi A., 2017 | India | Women with diabetes | E:41; C1:42; C2:41 | Yoga | 60 min | Twice weekly | C1: other active exercises (physical activity); C2: nonexercise | 12 weeks | (1)HbA1c, FBG (2) TC, BMI |
|
Hegde S. V., 2011 | India | People with type 2 diabetes | E:60; C:63 | Yoga | n.r. | Three times weekly | Nonexercise | 12 weeks | (1)HbA1c, FBG, PPBG (2) BMI |
|
Keerthi G. S., 2017 | India | People with type 2 diabetes | E:62; C:62 | Yoga | 45 min | Three times weekly | Nonexercise | 12 weeks | (1) FBG | |
Gordon L. A., 2008 and Gordon L.,2008 | Cuba | People with type 2 diabetes | E:77; C1:77; C2:77 | Yoga | 60 min | 3–4 times per week | C1: other active exercises (conventional physical training); C2: Nonexercise | 24 weeks | (1)HbA1c, FBG (2)TG, TC, HDL-C, LDL-C, BMI |
|
Singh S., 2008 and Kyizom T., 2010 | India | People with type 2 diabetes | E:30; C:30 | Yoga | 45 min | 5 days per week | Nonexercise | 45 days | (1)FBG, PPBG (2)TG, TC, HDL-C, LDL-C, BMI |
|
Mullur R. S., 2016 | USA | People with type 2 diabetes | E:5; C:5 | Yoga | 10 min | n.r. | Nonexercise | 12 weeks | (1)HbA1c, FBG (2)BMI |
|
Yang K., 2009 | USA | People with type 2 diabetes | E:13; C:10 | Yoga | 60 min | Twice per week | Nonexercise | 12 weeks | (1)FBG (2)TG, TC, HDL-C, LDL-C |
|
Jyotsna V. P., 2013 | India | People with type 2 diabetes | E:36; C:28 | Yoga | n.r. | 7 days per week | Other active exercises (brisk walking) | 24 weeks | (1)HbA1c, FBG, PPBG | |
Nagarathna R., 2012 | India | People with type 2 diabetes | E:141; C:136 | Yoga | 60 min | 5–7 days per week | Other active exercises (physical exercises) | 36 weeks | (1)HbA1c, FBG, PPBG (2)TG, TC, HDL-C, LDL-C |
|
Habibi N., 2013 | Iran | Women with T2DM | E:16; C:10 | Yoga | 75 min | Three times weekly | n.r. | 12 weeks | (1)FBG (2)BMI |
|
Shantakumari N., 2012 and Shantakumari N., 2013 | India | People with type 2 diabetes | E:50; C:50 | Yoga | 60 min | 7 days per week | Nonexercise | 12 weeks | (1)FBG, PPBG (2)TG, TC, HDL-C, LDL-C, BMI |
|
Vaishali K., 2012 | India | People with type 2 diabetes | E:27; C:30 | Yoga | 45–60 min | 6 days per week | Nonexercise | 12 weeks | (1)HbA1c, FBG (2)TC, TG, HDL-C, LDL-C |
|
Liu X., 2011 | Australia | People with type 2 diabetes | E:20; C:21 | Qigong | 1–1.5 hour | Three times weekly | Nonexercise | 12 weeks | (1)HbA1c, FBG, PPBG (2)HDL-C, TG |
|
Sun G. C., 2010 | USA | Adults with type 2 diabetes | E:11; C1:10; C2:11 | Qigong | 30–60 min | Three times weekly | C1: nonexercise; C2: Other active exercises (the progressive resistance training) | 12 weeks | (1)HbA1c, FBG; | |
Tsujiuchi T., 2002 | Japan | Adults with type 2 diabetes | E:16; C:10 | Qigong | 2 h | n.r. | Nonexercise | 16 weeks | (1)HbA1c |
E: experimental; C: control; FBG: fasting blood glucose; HbA1c: glycated hemoglobin; TC: total cholesterol; TG: triglycerides; HDL-C: high-density lipoprotein cholesterol; LDL-C: low-density lipoprotein cholesterol; BMI: body mass index; n.r.: not reported.