Skip to main content
. 2020 Feb 13;15(2):e0217956. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0217956

Table 1. Species delimitation methods based on multi-locus nuDNA sequences used in this study.

Method Input Category Reference Description SD Criteria
STRUCTURE alignment of
phased alleles
PG Pritchard et al. [26]
Falush et al. [53]
Bayesian clustering method based on the estimation of allele frequencies ΔK and plateau methods
Haplowebs alignment of
phased alleles
PG Flot et al. [30] Allele-sharing method, in which groups of individuals sharing a unique pool of alleles are connected by curves. Group of individuals constituting a field for recombination [FFR]
Conspecificity matrix (CM) Conspecificity scores PG Debortoli et al. [31] The conspecificity matrix was generated by calculating for each pair of individuals a conspecificity score, i.e., the number of markers supporting conspecificity in haploweb analyses. Number of markers supporting the hypothesis of conspecificity
BPP
(Bayesian Phylogenetics and Phylogeography)
alignment of consensus sequences MSC Yang and Rannala [64] Bayesian method based on the MSC model, in which a reversible-jump Markov chain Monte Carlo algorithm is used to calculate the posterior probabilities of species delimitations. Probability
≥ 0.95
STACEY
(Species Tree and Classification Estimation, Yarely)
alignment of
phased alleles
MSC Jones [24] Bayesian method implemented in BEAST 2 [65] for the inference of a “species or minimal clusters tree” (SMC) under the birth-death-collapse tree prior and without the requirement of a guide tree. Probability
≥ 0.95
Individual assignment of alleles: present study
*BEAST
(Species Tree Ancestral Reconstruction in BEAST)
alignment of
phased alleles
MSC
+
P
Program: Heled and Drummond [19];
Individual assignment of alleles: present study
Bayesian method implemented in BEAST 2 [65] based on the MSC model Probability
≥ 0.95
Bootstrap Analysis of Haplotypes alignment of
phased haplotypes
PG+
+
P
Present study Bootstrap consensus tree
reconstructed with ML, MP or NJ methods
Bootstrap
≥ 90
Supermatrix
MrBayes
alignment of consensus sequences P Ronquist et al. [46] Bayesian inference of phylogeny Probability
≥ 0.95
PhyML Guindon et al. [47] ML method for tree construction Bootstrap
≥ 90
SuperTRI
(SuperTree with Reliability Indices)
Weighted binary matrix of node support for each locus P Ropiquet et al. [20] Three measures are calculated to estimate the reliability of the nodes (SBP, MPP and NRep) using the branch support values (PP) of all phylogenetic hypotheses produced during the separate Bayesian analyses of the 21 introns (1) SBP ≥ 90
(2) MPP ≥ 0.1
(3) NRep ≥ 2

SD: Species delimitation; PG: Population Genetics; MSC: Multispecies Coalescent; P: Phylogenetic methods; SBP: Supertree Boostrap Percentage; MPP: Mean Posterior Probability

Rep: Reproducibility Index; SPR: Subtree Pruning and Re-grafting