Skip to main content
. 2020 Feb 13;15(2):e0228533. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0228533

Table 1. Characteristics of included studies.

Study Age Sample size/AR cases Study type Measurement-AR Measurement-sleep outcome Outcomes
Roxbury et al., 2018 45.6 (44.0–47.11) 5556/1797 Cross-sectional Self-reported Self-reported Sleep duration, SDB, snoring, OSA, insomnia, restless sleep, use of sleeping pills, daytime dysfunction
Loekmanwidjaja et al., 2018 4–10 167/112 Case-controlled Medical records Self-reported Sleep duration, daytime sleepiness
Lai et al., 2018 <18 655529/327928 Cohort Medical records Medical records OSA, nocturnal enuresis
Filiz et al., 2018 8–18 287/143 Cross-sectional Medical records, clinical examination, and skin prick test Face-to-face interview Sleep duration, restless sleep, PSQI outcomes, daytime dysfunction
Zhou et al., 2017 47±0.2 240000000/19100000 Cross-sectional Self-reported Self-reported Sleep duration
Zheng et al., 2017 18–70 171/65 Cross-sectional Medical records, clinical examination, and skin prick test PSG Sleep duration, OSA, PSG outcomes
Tsai et al., 2017 5–18 8516/4191 Case-controlled Medical records, clinical examination Medical records Nocturnal enuresis
Nguyen-Hoang et al., 2017 9.5±2.1 85/52 Case-controlled Clinical examination Medical records OSA
Kim et al., 2017 68.3±5.6 348/57 Cross-sectional Self-reported PSG SDB, PSG outcomes, PSQI outcomes
Hui et al., 2017 49.61±16.27 1028/- Cross-sectional Medical records Medical records OSA
Di et al., 2016 3–14 135/57 Case-controlled Medical records, clinical examination, and skin prick test PSG PSG outcomes
Trikojat et al., 2015 18–45 83/41 Case-controlled Medical records, clinical examination, and skin prick test Self-reported Sleep duration, PSQI outcomes, daytime dysfunction
Poachanukoon et al., 2015 10.6±2.5 175/65 Case-controlled Medical records, clinical examination, and skin prick test Self-reported Sleep duration, difficult waking up, snoring, morning headache, mouth breathing, night sweating, nocturnal enuresis, OSA daytime sleepiness, restless sleep, SDB, sleep bruxism
Ng et al., 2014 15.3±1.7 175/65 Cohort Self-reported Self-reported Snoring
Cai et al., 2013 - 1993/123 Cross-sectional Medical records Self-reported OSA
Zhang et al., 2012 46.3±5.1 2291/211 Cohort Self-reported Self-reported Restless sleep
So et al., 2012 9.2 (7.7–10.7) 6381/2661 Cross-sectional Self-reported Self-reported Night sweating
Park et al., 2012 20–68 112/37 Case-controlled Clinical examination and skin prick test PSG and self-reported Sleep duration, AHI, PSG outcomes, ESS
Meng et al., 2011 18–60 128/98 Case-controlled Self-reported PSG PSG outcomes
Li et al., 2010 5–14 6369/2823 Cross-sectional Self-reported Self-reported Snoring
Rimmer et al., 2009 >18 20/10 Case-controlled Self-reported Actigraphy Sleep duration
Hiraki et al., 2008 39.4±9.6 852/112 Cross-sectional Self-reported Self-reported Daytime sleepiness, snoring, ESS
Dixon et al., 2006 ≥15 1969/1133 Cohort Self-reported Self-reported ESS, PSQI outcomes
Sogut et al., 2005 8.1±1.9 992/332 Case-controlled Self-reported Self-reported Snoring
Ng et al., 2005 6–12 3047/1242 Cross-sectional Self-reported Self-reported Daytime sleepiness, OSA
Chng et al., 2004 4–7 9362/674 Cross-sectional Self-reported Self-reported Snoring
Anuntaseree et al., 2001 7.25±0.58 255/14 Cross-sectional Self-reported Self-reported Snoring

AR: allergic rhinitis; ESS: Epworth Sleepiness Scale; HS: habitual snoring; NAR: non-allergic rhinitis; OSA: obstructive sleep apnea; PSG: polysomnography; PSQI: Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index; REM: rapid eye movement; SDB: sleep-disordered breathing.