Skip to main content
. 2020 Feb 7;11:41. doi: 10.3389/fgene.2020.00041

Table 5.

Comparison of normalization methods used, including execution time (rounded to nearest five seconds), visualization, and classification rate across all data sets.

Category BASiCS GRM Linnorm SAMstrt SCnorm scran Simple Norm
Mouse Embryonic Data (sec) 230 35 <5 <5 760 <5 <5
Mouse Lung Data (sec) 510 60 <5 5 1180 <5 <5
Mouse Embryonic Sim Data (sec) 110 15 <5 <5 110 <5 <5
Human Embryonic Data (sec) _ _ <5 _ 370 <5 <5
Classification (Spike-In Genes) *** * ** * *** ** **
Visualization (Spike-In Genes) ** * ** * ** ** **
Classification (Non-Spike-In) _ _ * _ ** ** **
Visualization (Non-Spike-In) _ _ * _ ** * **

A ‘***' indicates that the method showed exemplary performance overall, a ‘**' indicates satisfactory performance overall, and a ‘*' indicates some shortcoming in performance compared to other methods. ‘_' indicates that the method is not applicable for this type of data. Two variants exist for the Mouse Embryonic Sim Data, but they had negligible differences in execution time.