Table 1.
Comparisons of the advantages and drawbacks of integrated and single liquid biopsy biomarkers.
Clinical stages | Features and Drawbacks of Single TAM | Categories and Advantages of Integrated TAM | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Features | Shortcomings | |||
Early diagnosis | ctDNA | Can detect a minimum of 0.005% abundance of mutant alleles. Its concentration correlates to tumor size and stage 17. |
Limited sensitivity in the detection of non-necrotic cancers 78. | Elementary integration: Structure-based IsoPSATM assay based on PSA measurement, provides a net benefit against other protocols 26. Meanwhile combination of ten exosomal miRNAs yielded 0.99 sensitivity and 1.00 specificity in detection of early-stage ovarian cancer 9. Intermediate integration: exoRNA-ctDNA integration in the plasma of NSCLC patients improved the sensitivity of EGFR mutation detection from 26% to 74% 37. Advanced integration: CancerSEEK combines ctDNA and CP with machine learning and has achieved 98% sensitivity and a <1% false positive rate for the detection of five cancer types 7. |
CP | Convenient detection | Less informative about tumor mutations79. | ||
EVs | Exosomes containing uncontaminated DNA, RNA and proteins provide outstanding specificity and sensitivity 21. | Lack of spatial and temporal tumor heterogeneity. | ||
CTCs | A high concentration (≥5 CTCs/7.5 mL) indicates higher risk of early cancer progression. | CTCs in the blood are rare. | ||
Therapy management (Postope-ration and prognosis | ctDNA | Short circulating time contributes to the monitoring of tumor evolution in real-time 80. | Less efficient in analyzing drug-resistance mechanisms. | Elementary integration: DNA sequencing mutations in exosomes is reliable in monitoring pancreatic cancer to establish curative surgical therapy (41). Intermediate integration: exoRNA-ctDNA integration increases the sensitivity of EGFR mutations detection in plasma to monitor responses to therapy 37. CEA-ctDNA integration predicts recurrence after adjuvant chemotherapy 81. Advanced integration: Combination of liquid biopsy (biological information from CTCs) and MRI (anatomy and physiological information) provides additional information than either modality alone 82. |
CTCs | Key checkpoints in metastasis. Strong prognostic factor for overall survival in patients. Assist in the establishment of a CTC-derived xenograft (CDX) model to search for druggable targets 83. |
Inefficiency in discovering intratumoral heterogeneity Inefficiency clonal evolution of cancers after targeted therapy. |
||
EVs | Exosomes miRNA profiles can predict survival after therapy 84 . | Therapy-induced tumor heterogeneity and EV diversity. |