Table 1.
a.) Studies addressing safety outcomes | ||||||||
Authors and country | Setting/data sources | Study design/ period | Inclusion (I) and exclusion (E) criteria | Intervention/comparison | Final N/ N potentially eligible/ (%) | N Inter-vention group | N Control group | Outcomes |
Munoz et al., 2014; USA [30] | 3 National Institutes of Health’s Vaccine Treatment Evaluation Units | RCT, 2008–2012 |
I: Women, 18–45 years of age, with no chronic conditions, a singleton, uncomplicated pregnancy with normal first- or second-trimester screening test results; E: Women who received Tdap or any tetanus-containing vaccine within the prior 2 years |
Tdap (Adacel®) at 30–32 WG vs. placebo | – | 33 | 15 | vaccine-related adverse outcomes; perinatal complications; pertussis illness in infants |
Hoang et al., 2016; Vietnam [31] | Primary care | RCT, 2012–2013 | I: Women, 18–41 years of age, with low risk for complications. E: Women with any serious underlying medical condition; febrile illness within 72 h before injection, receipt of TT vaccine in the past month; receipt of Tdap in the past 10 years; receipt of a vaccine, blood product or experimental medicine 4 weeks before or after injection; previous severe reaction to any vaccine | Tdap (Adacel®) at 20–30 WG vs. TT | – | 51 | 48 | short-term vaccine-related adverse outcomes; obstetric and perinatal complications |
Halperin et al., 2018; Canada [32] | not specified, most likely outpatient hospital care | RCT, 2007–2014 | I: Healthy, pregnant women 18–45 years of age assessed at ≥30 weeks’ gestation to be at low risk for complications; E: Women with high obstetrical risk, history of significant medical disorder or physician-diagnosed pertussis or receipt of Td or Tdap in the last 5 years; sensitivity to Td or Tdap, receipt of blood products or immunoglobulin within 3 months of study entry (except rhesus Ig), or receipt of any vaccines within 2 weeks of study vaccine (except for influenza vaccine). | Tdap (Adacel®) ≥30 WG vs. TT | 273/304 (90%) | 134 | 138 | acute safety and pregnancy-related outcomes |
Berenson et al., 2016; USA [33] | University hospital | RCS, 2012–2014 | I: Singleton pregnancies delivered ≥27 WG; E: Women with < 4 clinic visits during pregnancy | Tdap (vaccine not specified) during pregnancy vs. no Tdap | – | 1109 | 650 | obstetric and perinatal complications |
DeSilva et al., 2016; USA [34] | 7 Vaccine Safety Datalink sites (Analysis of health insurance-based electronic health records) | RCS, 2007–2013 | I: Singleton live births, women continuously insured from 6 months before LMP through 6 weeks postpartum, with ≥1 outpatient visit(s) during pregnancy. I Infants: birth weight and gestational age available; enrolled in health insurance for ≥4 months in first YoL, with ≥1 outpatient visit(s); E: Infants with exposures increasing risk for structural birth defects (maternal diabetes or use of teratogenic medications, congenital infections, and chromosomal abnormalities) | Tdap (vaccine not specified) during pregnancy vs. no Tdap | 324,463 singleton live births | 41,654 | 282,809 | microcephaly and other selected major structural birth defects |
DeSilva et al., 2017; USA [35] | 7 Vaccine Safety Datalink sites (Analysis of health insurance-based electronic health records) | RCS, 2010–2013 | I: Singleton live births, women continuously insured from 6 months before LMP through 6 weeks postpartum, with ≥1 outpatient visit(s) during pregnancy. I Infants: birth weight and gestational age available; enrolled in health insurance for ≥4 months in first YoL, with ≥1 outpatient visit(s); E: Women who received live virus vaccines during pregnancy | Tdap mostly at 27–36 WG (vaccine not specified) vs. no Tdap | 197,654 /243,981 (81%) live births | 45,008 | 152,556 | obstetric and perinatal complications |
Donegan et al., 2014; UK [36] | Primary care practices, (650 primary care general practice databases, 12.5 million patients) | RCS, 2012–2013 Tdap- and 2010–2012 control group |
I a.) Short-term AE risk: women ≥12 years of age who received pertussis-containing vaccination during pregnancy with ≥28 days of follow-up data after vaccination; I b.) Risk throughout pregnancy: women ≥12 years of age with a recorded pregnancy outcome and estimated gestational age with follow-up of at least 44 weeks after the date of the LMP. I Historical cohort: women ≥12 years of age with a recorded pregnancy outcome from October 2010 to September 2012 and no record of a vaccine containing pertussis during or after pregnancy |
TdaP-IPV (Repevax®) during pregnancy vs. no ap-vaccine | a.): 17,560/ 20,074 (87%); b.): 6185/20,074 (31%) | 18,523 | obstetric and perinatal complications | |
Griffin et al., 2018; New Zealand [37] | Nationwide linked administrative health databases | RCS, 2013 | I: All pregnant women who reached 28–38 WG in 2013; E Women: pregnancies < 20 WG or missing maternal or gestational age; E Infants: live born babies < 28 WG or BW < 400 g | Tdap (Boostrix®) at 28–38 WG vs. no Tdap | 68,550/73,817 (93%) | 8178 | 60,372 | obstetric, perinatal and neonatal outcomes |
Kharbanda et al., 2014; USA [38] | 2 Vaccine Safety Datalink sites (Analysis of health insurance-based electronic health records) | RCS, 2010–2012 | I: Women 14–49 years of age at delivery with singleton pregnancies ending in live birth, continuously insured from 6 months before LMP through 6 weeks postpartum, ≥1 outpatient visit at an affiliated site and with birth weight and gestational age recorded; E: Women who received live virus vaccines during pregnancy or who received Tdap in the 7 days after the estimated pregnancy start date or in the 7 days before delivery; incomplete birth data | Tdap (mainly Adacel®) from 8 days after LMP to 8 days before delivery vs. no Tdap | 123,494/300,607 (41%) | 26,229 | 97,265 | obstetric and perinatal complications |
Kharbanda et al., 2016; USA [39] | Vaccine Safety Datalink sites (Analysis of health insurance-based electronic health records) | RCS, 2007–2013 | see Kharbanda, 2014 | Tdap (vaccine not specified) during pregnancy vs. no Tdap | 427,097/631,256 (68%) | 53,885 | 109,253 | acute safety endpoints in 0–42 days after vaccination |
Layton et al., 2017; USA [40] | MarketScan Commercial Claims and Encounters (Truven Health Analytics) claims databases of employer-based commercial health care insurance | RCS, 2010–2014 | I: Women with livebirth or stillbirth deliveries; only first observed pregnancy per women; E: Women who delivered at ≤26 WG; women ≤18 years in 13 states with universal childhood immunization policies | Tdap (vaccine not specified) at ≥27 WG; Tdap < 27 WG vs. no Tdap | NR | ≥27 WG: 123,780 < 27 WG: 25,037 | 871,177 | acute safety endpoints in 0–42 days after vaccination; obstetrical and perinatal complications |
Maertens et al., 2016; Belgium [15] | 5 hospitals in Antwerp, Belgium | PCS, 2012–2014 | I: Women 18–40 years of age with low risk for complications. E: Same as Hoang et al. | Tdap (Boostrix®) at 22–33 WG vs. no Tdap | NR | 57 | 42 | acute safety outcomes obstetric and perinatal complications |
Morgan et al., 2015; USA [41] | Parkland clinic-based pre-natal and obstetrical care centers in Dallas County with centralized electronic medical charting system | RCS, 2013–2014 | I: All women who delivered at Parkland | Tdap (vaccine not specified) at ≥32 WG vs. no Tdap | NR | 7152 | 226 | obstetric and neonatal outcomes |
Shakib et al., 2013; USA [42] | Intermountain Healthcare database, Utah | RCS, 2005–2009 | I: Pregnant women 12–45 years of age and their babies; E: Women whose pregnancy start date could not be determined; women who had documentation of Tdap vaccine within 3 days prior to delivery | Tdap (vaccine not specified) at any time during pregnancy vs. no Tdap | 162,448 | 138 | 552 | obstetric and perinatal complications; congenital anomalies, complex chronic conditions in 1st YoL |
b.) Studies addressing effectiveness outcomes | ||||||||
Authors/country | Setting/data source | study design/period | Participants (Inclusion (I) and exclusion (E) criteria) | Intervention/comparator | N | Pertussis cases | control group | outcomes |
Amirthalingam et al., 2014, UK [43] | notification data from enhanced surveillance for pertussis cases; and sentinel primary care data (Clinical Practice Research Datalink) for vaccination coverage calculations | RCS; screening method, 2008–2013 | I: infants < 3 months of age; E: unknown maternal vaccination status, vaccination given within 7 days of birth; first primary infant vaccination before 7 days of disease onset | maternal Tdap-IPV (Repevax®) at 28–38 WG vs. no Tdap | NR | 71 | 26,684 | laboratory confirmed pertussis at < 2 and < 3 months of age |
Amirthalingam et al., 2016, UK [16] | see Amirthalingam et al., 2014, UK [43] | RCS screening method, 2012–2015 | see Amirthalingam et al., 2014, UK [43] | maternal Tdap-IPV (Repevax®, Boostrix-Polio®) at 28–38 WG vs. no Tdap | NR | 192 | 72,781 | laboratory confirmed pertussis at < 2 and < 3 months of age; pertussis related deaths |
Baxter et al., 2017, USA [44] | Kaiser Permanente Northern California (KPNC) medical care data | RCS, 2010–2015 | I: infants born in KPNC hospitals 2010–2015; full term (> = 37 WG); enrolled in Kaiser health plan by age 4 months; mother continuously enrolled in KPNC health plan; mother born before 1996 | maternal Tdap vaccination (Boostrix®, Covaxis®) at least 8 days before birth vs. no Tdap | 148,981 | 17 | 148,964 | laboratory confirmed pertussis at < 2 months of age |
Becker-Dreps et al., 2018, USA [45] | commercial insurance claims data | RCS, 2010–2014 | I: infants </= 18 months of age, delivered between June 2010 and Dec. 2014; First delivery per women; singleton deliveries occurring > 26 WG; E: non-continuous insurance enrolment from pregnancy onset until 7 days post-delivery | maternal Tdap vaccination (vaccine not specified) vs. no Tdap | 632,825 | 112 | 632,713 | laboratory confirmed pertussis at < 2 months of age; pertussis-related hospitalization |
Bellido-Blasco et al., 2017, Spain [46] | community-based data; cases were identified via computerized mandatory notification system | CCS, 2015–2016 | I: cases: unvaccinated infants < 3 months old, with confirmed pertussis; controls: three paired controls by age (difference less than 15 days) per case; two controls: same paediatrician/family doctor as case; third control: same maternity clinic as case; controls: unvaccinated | maternal Tdap vaccination (vaccine not specified) vs. no Tdap | 88 | 22 | 66 | laboratory confirmed pertussis at < 3 months of age |
Dabrera et al., 2015, England and Wales [47] | community-based data; cases were identified via notification system; controls were 2 infants born consecutively after pertussis case from the same practice | CCS, 2012–2013 | E infants: aged ≥8 weeks, unknown vaccination status of mother; E controls: known clinical or microbiological diagnosis of pertussis | maternal Tdap-IPV (Repevax®) at any time in pregnancy vs. no Tdap | 113 | 58 | 55 | laboratory confirmed pertussis at <2 months ofage |
Saul et al., 2017, Australia [48] | cases were identified via notification system; controls: infant born +/−3 days as case in the maternity clinic of the local health district in which the case was notified | CCS, 2015–2016 | E controls: cough illness within two weeks of the onset of the illness in the matched case | maternal Tdap at ≤2 weeks before birth with a 3-component acellular pertussis vaccine vs. no Tdap | 96 | 48 | 48 | laboratory confirmed pertussis at < 3 months of age; pertussis-related hospitalization |
Skoff et al., 2017, USA [49] | cases were identified via surveillance in 6 Emerging Infection Program Network sites; controls were hospital-matched | CCS, 2011–2014 | I: infants ≥2 days old, residing in the catchment area on their cough onset date, were born in a hospital in their state of residence, were delivered at ≥37 WG, were not adopted or in foster care, and did not live in a residential care facility. E controls: pertussis diagnosis prior to the cough onset date of the corresponding case infant | any pertussis-containing vaccine at any time in pregnancy vs. no Tdap | 6252 | 240 | 535 | laboratory confirmed pertussis at <2 months of age; pertussis-related hospitalization |
ap-vaccine acellular pertussis vaccine, BW birth weight, LMP last menstrual period, NR not reported, RCT randomized controlled trial, RCS retrospective cohort study, TT Tetanus-vaccine, YoL year of life, CCS case-control-study, dT5aP-IPV diphteria-tetanus-5-component-acelluar-pertussis-inactivated-polio-vaccine, dT3aP-IPV diphteria-tetanus-3-component-acelluar-pertussis-inactivated-polio-vaccine, NR not reported, WG weeks of gestation