Skip to main content
. 2019 Dec 30;10(1):63. doi: 10.3390/biom10010063

Table 2.

Advantages and disadvantages of some dressings used for the treatment of wounds.

Formulation Type Indications Advantages Disadvantages References
Foams
  • They are indicated for wounds with moderate to high levels of exudates.

  • They are semipermeable and have good porosity;

  • They provide thermal insulation;

  • They ensure a moist environment;

  • They are suitable for sensitive and fragile skin;

  • They have good absorption capacity;

  • They can reduce over granulation;

  • They allow atraumatic removal.

  • They do not offer mechanical protection;

  • They are not suitable for treatment of burns.

[13,19,25,26,27]
Hydrogels
  • They are indicated for dry necrotic wounds and minimally exuding wounds.

  • They have high water content and maintain a moist environment;

  • They are clear or transparent, allowing the wound monitoring;

  • They promote re-epithelialization;

  • They facilitate autolytic debridement of necrotic area.

  • They have weak mechanical properties;

  • They are used in combination with a secondary dressing (such as foams).

[19,27,28,29]
Hydrocolloids
  • They are suitable for partial- or full-thickness acute and chronic wounds.

  • They maintain a moist environment;

  • They absorb minimal to moderate amounts of drainage;

  • They are easy to be removed;

  • They facilitate autolytic debridement of necrotic area;

  • They contribute to pain management;

  • They provide a barrier to external microorganism;

  • They promote re-epithelialization;

  • They promote acidification which can inhibit bacteria growth.

  • They can have toxicity;

  • They have weak mechanical properties;

  • They can have unpleasant odor.

[19,27,30]
Films
  • They can be used as primary or secondary dressings. As primary dressing, they are indicated for dry, superficial wound. As a secondary dressing they can be used combined with foam dressings in heavier exuding wounds.

  • They are semipermeable (impermeability to water, bacteria, and dirt; but permeable to wet vapors);

  • They maintain a moist environment;

  • They are flexible;

  • They are clear or transparent, allowing the wound monitoring.

  • They do not absorb exudates;

  • They generally require a border of dry, intact skin for application (for adhesiveness);

  • They can damage the epidermal skin layer during the removal.

[19,20,27,31]
Membranes
  • They are indicated for infected wounds with moderate to heavily exuding wounds.

  • They have high capacity to absorb exudate (up to 20 times their weight);

  • They are permeable to wet vapors;

  • They maintain a moist environment;

  • They are flexible and biodegradable;

  • They minimize bacterial infection.

  • They can cause excessive dehydration (not indicated to dry wounds);

  • Some membranes require secondary dressings (to avoid dryness).

[19,27,31]