Dijkstra‐Eshuis 2013.
Methods | RCT | |
Participants |
Time of recruitment: pre‐operative Population: men having a laparoscopic radical prostatectomy (whole population, with or without UI) Included: patients with prostate cancer, undergoing laparoscopic radical prostatectomy Excluded: neurological disorders, a medical history with invasive perineal and/or rectal surgery, preoperatively existing stress urinary incontinence, radiation, ≥ 75 years Age (mean, SD): A 63.7 (5.3); B 63.7 (5.3) Dropouts: 9 from A (1 unable to understand Dutch, 3 post‐operative radiotherapy, 1 oesophageal cancer, 3 discontinued intervention at own request, 1 excluded due to poor compliance) 8 from B (2 post operative radiotherapy, 1 pelvic lymph node dissection, 1 died of cause unrelated to prostate cancer, 5 discontinued intervention at own request, 1 prolonged catheter) Not differential dropout Baseline characteristics: comparable at baseline |
|
Interventions |
Time of intervention: pre‐operative (+ postoperative treatment for all men) A (56): 30 mins of guided PFMT + biofeedback weekly for 4 weeks before surgery, received written instructions to: carry out two sets of 30 contractions during abdominal breathing, one breath between each contraction; restart PFMT after catheter removal (7 to 10 days after surgery) B (46): received written instructions on PFMT after catheter removal (7 to 10 days after surgery) All men were seen before surgery by a physiotherapist, who explained relevant anatomy, anal visual inspection and digital palpation, biofeedback registration with rectal probe All patients received PFMT + biofeedback and/or electrical stimulation if still incontinent after 6 weeks Duration of treatment Follow up: 6 weeks, 3 months, 6 months, 9 months and 12 months after surgery |
|
Outcomes |
Primary outcome (number of men with UI) Number of incontinent men (leakage on 24 hour pad test) 12 months: A 20/58; B 9/45 Other outcomes Number of continent men after 1 year (no leakage at all on 24 hour pad test) 12 months: 38/58; B 36/45 Adverse effects: A 0/56; B 0/46 Quality of life King’s Health Questionnaire (KHQ) (mean (SD) N): General health 12 months: A 24.48 (50.7) 56; B 29.64 (50.7) 46 Role limitations 12 months: A 21.36 (22.2) 56; B 17.73 (22.2) 46 Physical limitations 12 months: A 16.49 (15.45) 56; B 13.48 (15.45) 46 Social limitations 12 months: A 7.98 (24.8) 56; B 4.15 (24.8) 46 Personal 12 months: A 18.72 (4.4) 56; B 19.62 (4.4) 46 Emotional 12 months: A 5.08 (7.0) 56; B 4.24 (7.0) 46 Sleep or energy disturbance: A 9.13 (39.0) 56; B 6.13 (39.0) 46 Symptom severity: A 14.62 (86.1) 56; B 10.93 (86.1) 46 |
|
Notes | Trial was stopped early because interim analysis found no benefit for group A Additional information supplied by author |
|
Risk of bias | ||
Bias | Authors' judgement | Support for judgement |
Random sequence generation (selection bias) | Low risk | “Computer‐generated random numbers with block randomization and variable block size” |
Allocation concealment (selection bias) | Low risk | "central computer system" |
Blinding of participants (performance bias) | Unclear risk | “participants were also blinded until their first visit to the pelvic floor physiotherapist” |
Blinding of personnel (performance bias) | Low risk | “The pelvic floor physiotherapists were blinded to randomization” (to pre‐operative randomisation) |
Blinding of outcome assessment (detection bias) All outcomes | Low risk | Outcome assessor blinded |
Incomplete outcome data (attrition bias) All outcomes | Low risk | 9 from A (1 unable to understand Dutch, 3 post‐operative radiotherapy, 1 oesophageal cancer, 3 discontinued intervention at own request, 1 excluded due to poor compliance) 8 from B (2 post‐operative radiotherapy, 1 pelvic lymph node dissection, 1 died of cause unrelated to prostate cancer, 5 discontinued intervention at own request, 1 prolonged catheter á demeure). Not differential dropout |
Selective reporting (reporting bias) | Low risk | All outcomes in methods were reported |
Financial support | Low risk | None |
Approved by medical ethics committee | Low risk | “Medical ethical approval was obtained from the Medical Ethics committee of our university hospital” |
Informed consent | Low risk | “Informed consent was obtained” |
ITT analysis | Low risk | Assumed from flow diagram |