Skip to main content
. 2020 Feb 18;20:82. doi: 10.1186/s12872-020-01337-z

Table 1.

Main characteristics of included studies. RCT, randomized controlled trial; BMI, body mass index; SBP, systolic blood pressure; LDL, low density lipoprotein; NA, not available

Author, Year Study design Intervention Duration of trial (week) Number Age Mean Body weight (kg) Mean Waist circumference (cm) Mean BMI (kg, m2) Mean SBP (mmHg) Mean LDL (mmol, L)
Katcher, 2008 [25] RCT Whole grain 12 50 NA 103.1 vs 106.2 82 vs 83.2 NA 123 vs 130 2.83 vs 2.93
K. Rave, 2007 [26] RCT Whole grain 4 NA NA 97.5 vs 98.8 NA 33.2 vs 33.7 131 vs 134 3.8 vs 3.8
HARRIS JACKSON, 2014 [27] RCT Whole grain 12 25 VS 25 45.8 vs 46.4 99.5 vs 99.7 NA 33.5 vs 32.9 NA NA
Maria Lankinen, 2014 [28] RCT Whole grain 12 34 Vs 35 NA NA 106.3 vs 105.8 31.4 vs 31 135 vs 139 3.2 vs 3.4
Roager HM, 2017 [29] RCT Whole grain 8 50 Vs 50 NA 85.4 vs 86.1 100.1 vs 100.4 NA 126.2 vs 124.2 3.2 vs 3.2
Kirwan, 2016 [30] RCT Whole grain 8 33 Vs 33 NA 93.2 vs 93.7 96.4 vs 95.5 32.9 vs 33.1 NA 2.76 vs 2.76
I.A.Brownlee, 2010 [31] RCT Whole grain 16 33 VS 33 45.9 vs 45.6 86.7 vs 86.7 NA 30 vs 30 125.5 vs 127.3 3.2 vs 3.2
Steven K. Malin, 2018 [32] RCT Whole grain 8 14 VS 14 37.9 vs 37.9 97.9 vs 97.9 NA 33.8 vs 33.9 NA NA
SCHUTTE, 2018 [33] RCT Whole grain 12 25 vs 25 61 vs 61 84.6 vs 86.2 102.2 vs 103.4 27.6 vs 28 NA NA
Bernard J. Venn, 2010 [34] RCT Whole grain 72 53 vs 55 42 vs 42 99 vs 95 NA 36.1 vs 34.7 NA NA
P. Hajihashemi, 2014 [35] RCT Whole grain 6 44 vs 44 11.2 vs 11.2 51.26 vs 51.26 80.69 vs 80.69 23.57 vs 23.57 NA NA
K. Nelson, 2016 [36] RCT Whole grain 4 10 vs 10 NA NA NA 30.77 vs 31 133.3 vs 132.1 3.27 vs 3.12
Paula Tighe, 2013 [37] RCT Whole grain 12 73 vs 63 51.6 vs 51.8 NA 85.7 vs 90.9 28 vs 28 125.9 vs 131.2 3.45 vs 3.66
Mette Kristensen, 2017 [38] RCT Whole grain 12 30 vs 30 NA NA NA 28.5 vs 28.4 130 vs 130 3.7 vs 3.7
S. FATAHI, 2018 [39] RCT Whole grain, fruits and vegetables, both 10 25 vs 25 vs 25 36.7 vs 34.6 vs 39.9 NA NA 32.1 vs 32.3 vs 32.7 NA NA
Xue Li, 2016 [40] RCT Whole grain 4 60 vs 79 vs 80 vs 79 59 vs 59.73 vs 59.72 vs 59.44 NA NA NA 143.7 vs 147.2 vs 144.9 vs 147.1 NA
Kevin C. Maki, 2010 [41] RCT Whole grain 12 77 vs 67 50.1 vs 47.5 88.7 vs 87.6 104.5 vs 105.2 32 vs 32.2 NA 4 vs 3.99
V. D. F. de Mello, 2011 [42] RCT Whole grain, Healthy diet 12 34 vs 36 vs 34 58 vs 59 vs 59 89.2 vs 89.8 vs 89.5 106.3 vs 105.7 vs 105.7 31.4 vs 31.1 vs 30.9 135 vs 138 vs 139 3.2 vs 3.1 vs 3.4
A. Stefoskaneedham, 2017 [43] RCT Whole grain 12 30 vs 30 48.1 vs 48.6 87.1 vs 86.1 102.5 vs 105.3 31.2 vs 31.6 122.3 vs 126.2 3.2 vs 3.5
Kristensen, 2012 [44] RCT Whole grain 12 38 vs 34 NA 81.3 vs 83.5 97.3 vs 99 30 vs 30.4 133 vs 138 3.75 vs 3.75
J. Tovar, 2014 [45] RCT Whole grain 4 26 vs 26 NA NA NA NA NA NA
Mette Kristensen, 2017 [38] RCT Whole grain 12 81 vs 88 36.2 vs 35.3 80.2 vs 81.5 NA 30.2 vs 30.1 109.8 vs 111.2 2.9 vs 2.72