4.1. Analysis.
Comparison 4 Bupropion and nortriptyline. Adverse events, Outcome 1 Nortriptyline vs placebo. 'No report' = no information, 'None occurred' = explicit statement.
Nortriptyline vs placebo. 'No report' = no information, 'None occurred' = explicit statement | |||
---|---|---|---|
Study | Serious events | Other adverse events | Withdrawal due to AE |
Aveyard 2008 | 2 admissions to hospital (1 intervention, 1 control) with collapse or palpitations judged possibly caused by treatment | Dry mouth (80% vs 'more than half, OR 6.67, 5.12 to 8.69), Constipation (OR 2.06, 1.66 to 2.56) and Sweating (OR 1.37, 1.11 to 1.68) significantly more common | No report |
Da Costa 2002 | None occurred | No significant differences between groups. Dry mouth 44% vs 24%, constipation 29% vs 12%, irritation 18% vs 24%, anxiety 18% vs 28%. | No report |
Haggsträm 2006 | None occurred | Dry mouth (67.3% vs 31.4%) and drowsiness (19.2% vs 11.8%) significantly more common with nortriptyline Constipation (15.4% vs 9.8%) NS | No report |
Hall 1998 | None occurred | Dry mouth (78% vs 33%), lightheadedness (49% vs 22%), shaky hands (23% vs 11%) and blurry vision (16% vs 6%) were significantly more common. | 4 (4%) dropouts due to side effects in drug and 1 (1%) in placebo group. Total dropout rates 30% in drug and 17% in placebo groups |
Hall 2002 | None occurred | Dry mouth (72% vs 33%) and constipation ( 32% vs 14%) significantly more common with nortriptyline | No report |
Hall 2004 | None occurred | Dry mouth (85% vs 40%), lightheadedness (44% vs 22%), shaky hands (30% vs 14%) constipation (38% vs 15%), blurry vision (23% vs 7%), difficulty urinating (13% vs 2%), all p<0.01. Sexual difficulties (19% vs 2% p <0.02) | 4 (10%) in active brief treatment, 10 (25%) in active extended treatment, 9 (11%) in placebo stopped medication due to adverse effects (active vs placebo p=0.18, Fisher's exact test) |
Prochazka 1998 | None occurred | Dry mouth (64% vs 23%), dysgeusia (20% vs 8%), GI upset (41% vs 24%), drowsiness (24% vs 8%) significantly more common | 10 (9%) treatment withdrawal due to adverse events in nortriptyline group, vs 3 (3%) in placebo group. |
Prochazka 2004 | None occurred | Dry mouth (38% vs 8%) & sedation (20% vs 3%) significantly more common. | 10 (13%) discontinued nortriptyline including 1 subject with a normal baseline ECG who developed asymptomatic prolongation of QT interval, vs 1 placebo |
Wagena 2005 | One death in placebo group, previously hospitalised with dermatological reactions | Dry mouth (61% vs 20%), diarrhoea or constipation (48% vs 26%) and fatigue (20% vs 9%) significantly more common in nortriptyline group | 24% discontinued nortriptyline vs 9% placebo |