Skip to main content
. 2019 Dec 10;35(2):215–227. doi: 10.1002/mds.27919

Table 2.

Overview of studies exploring the therapeutic potential of noninvasive cerebellar stimulation techniques in patients with ET

Study N Intervention Sham Blinding Protocol Results
Gironell, 200283 10 1‐Hz cerebellar rTMS, applied 2 cm below the inion (butterfly coil) Yes Patients and outcome assessor 30 trains of 10 seconds with pauses of 30 seconds; crossover design
  • Improvement of tremor severity 5 minutes after real stimulation, but not 60 minutes after rTMS (FTMTRS and accelerometry)

Popa, 201386 11 Neuronavigation‐guided 1 Hz bilateral cerebellar rTMS (figure‐of‐eight coil) No N/A 15 minutes of stimulation of each cerebellar hemisphere during 5 consecutive days
  • Improvement of tremor severity, writing/drawing, and tremor‐related functional disability at days 5, 12, and 29

  • Increased functional connectivity between the cerebellum and the motor cortex at day 5

Gironell, 201484 10 tDCS; two cathodes 3 cm left and right from the inion, two anodes over the prefrontal areas Yes Patients and outcome assessor 20 minutes of stimulation, 2 mA; 5 days per week for 2 weeks; crossover design
  • No changes in tremor severity at days 10 and 40 (FTMTRS and accelerometry)

Bologna, 201581 16 Cerebellar cTBS, applied 1 cm below the inion and 3 cm to the right (figure‐of‐eight coil) Yes Patients and outcome assessor Triplets of 50‐Hz stimuli, repeated at 5 Hz for 40 seconds; crossover design
  • No excitability change in the left motor cortex

  • No change in tremor severity, amplitude, frequency, and reaching movements (FTMTRS and kinematics)

Helvaci Yilmaz, 201685 6 tDCS; two anodes over the dorsolateral prefrontal areas, cathode over the inion No N/A 20 minutes of stimulation, 2 mA; 5 days per week for 2 weeks; 1 month later, 5 more sessions every other day
  • No differences in TETRAS scores between baseline and day 20; lower TETRAS score at day 50

  • Improvement in ADL scores at days 20 and 50

Shin, 201987 22 1‐Hz cerebellar rTMS, applied 3 cm lateral and 1 cm inferior to the inion over both hemispheres (figure‐of‐eight coil) Yes Patients 20 trains of 30 seconds with pauses of 10 seconds over each cerebellar hemisphere; 5 consecutive days
  • Decrease in total FTMTRS score, including subscales A and B (clinical severity), but not C (daily life activities), immediately and after 4 weeks in both groups without significant group effect

TETRAS, The Essential Tremor Rating Scale; rTMS, repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation; FTMTRS, Fahn‐Tolosa‐Marin Tremor Rating Scale; cTBS, continuous theta burst stimulation; ADL, activities of dailyliving; N/A, not applicable.