Skip to main content
letter
. 2019 Dec 18;23(3):439–446. doi: 10.1111/ele.13441

Table 1.

Most probable model of extinction rate change as a function of species age per taxonomic group and latitudinal band

Clade Low latitude Mid latitude High latitude
Best model P_best P_const Best model P_best P_const Best model P_best P_const
Athyridida strongD 0.837 0.001 strongD 0.941 0.001 mildD 0.919 0.059
Auloporida mildD 0.515 0.014 strongD 0.537 0.018
Bellerophontidae strongD 0.787 0.002 strongD 0.981 0
Cystiphyllida strongD 0.498 0.026 strongD 0.600 0.035
Cystoporida mildD 0.602 0.021 strongD 0.886 0.003 mildI 0.493 0.154
Desmoceratidae strongD 0.625 0.025 strongD 0.958 0.001 strongD 0.587 0.101
Euomphalidae strongD 0.989 0 mildD 0.764 0.105
Favositida strongD 0.580 0.011 strongD 0.917 0.002
Fenestrida strongD 0.988 0 mildD 0.593 0.042 mildD 0.831 0.029
Lophospiridae strongD 0.996 0 strongD 0.921 0
Orthida strongD 0.726 0.003 strongD 0.979 0 strongD 0.488 0.027
Orthotetida strongD 0.938 0 strongD 0.972 0 constant 0.692 0.692
Productida strongD 0.616 0.001 strongD 0.500 0.002 strongD 0.810 0.001
Proetidae strongD 0.92 0.003 constant 0.184 0.184 constant 0.347 0.347
Pterineidae strongD 0.905 0.005 strongD 0.997 0
Rhabdomesida mildD 0.692 0.033 constant 0.385 0.385 mildD 0.764 0.021
Spiriferida strongD 0.988 0 strongD 0.666 0.003 strongD 0.855 0.001
Spiriferinida strongD 0.809 0.001 strongD 0.985 0 strongD 0.530 0.007
Stauriida strongD 0.897 0.002 strongD 0.765 0.008 strongD 0.603 0.041
Strophomenida mildD 0.796 0.024 strongD 0.982 0 strongD 0.675 0.008
Trepostomida mildD 0.763 0.056 strongD 0.623 0.011 mildD 0.790 0.064

The models are classified as strong decrease in the rate over time (strongD), mild decrease in the rate with species age (mildD), constant rate (constant), mild rate increase (mildI). The value P_best represents the probability associated to the most probable model as estimated by the ADE‐NN, while P_const is the probability associated with a model with constant extinction. Rejecting the latter when P_const < 0.16 yields a Type I error rate < 0.05 (see Methods). We found no instance of strong increase in the rate over time.