Table 2:
Summary of articles focused on Economic Stability and Education
Author/Year | Study Design | Objective | Number of Participants |
Sample population |
Setting | Impact on Outcome |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Durden, 2009 (39) | Retrospective, cross-sectional cohort | Evaluate the economic burden of privately insured patients with T2DM at two time points (2000 and 2005) | 21,592 in 2000 and 127,254 in 2005 (both with matched controls) | Two cohorts: patients with T2DM with medical and prescription claims from the MarketScan Commercial Claims and Encounters database for (1) 2000 and (2) 2005. Controls met the same criteria except a diagnosis of T2DM and requirements for anti-DM treatment regimen for 2000 & 2005. | Database of claims derived from health plans with fee-for-service, fully capitated, or partially capitated payment arrangements from 1/1/99 to 12/31/00 and from 1/1/04 to 12/31/05 | Adjusted health care costs of patients with T2DM were higher in both years studied (146% higher in 2000, $12,423 vs. $5058; p<0.001 and 136% higher in 2005, $12,733 vs. $5406; p<0.001). (Cost figures for 2000 were inflated to 12/2005 dollars using the medical care component of the Consumer Price Index). |
Lind, 2006 (63) | Retrospective, cross-sectional cohort | Investigate whether insurance coverage for complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) providers is associated with increased health care use and expenditures | 20,722 adults with diabetes (Enrollees with allowed claims=497,597; CAM users with DM=3,605) | Adult patients (18-64yrs) with T2DM who had both continuous enrollment in a single plan (directly regulated by the Every Category of Provider Law) and complete claims information in 2002 (Medicare, Medicaid, state-supplemental programs, self-insured plans all excluded) Controls: randomly chosen age and gender matched adults without T2DM (5 matches for each DM patient) | Claims data from two large insurers in Washington State for 2002 | CAM users had more outpatient visits (on average, 28 vs. 16) and had higher average annual expenditures ($8,736 vs. $7,356). CAM was not statistically associated with expenditures after adjusting. |
Rodbard, 2010 (75) | Cross-sectional, followed by prospective longitudinal (Study to Help Improve Early Evaluation and Management of Risk Factors Leading to Diabetes (SHIELD) Study) | Assess whether patients with T2DM have a greater economic burden (prescription medications and out-of-pocket expenses) compared to patients without T2DM | 12,237 (patients with T2DM=3,551 and patients without T2DM=8,686) | Adult patients with T2DM | National survey of adult patients with T2DM or risk factors for DM in over 200,000 households in the US | Patients with T2DM had a significantly higher total (mean) number of prescription medications vs. patients without T2DM (6.2 vs. 4.1, p<0.001); therefore, patients with T2DM had 2% more prescription meds (β=2.09). Patients with T2DM had significantly higher mean out-of-pocket healthcare expenses annually (>200%) vs. those without T2DM ($1158 vs. $925, p<0.001); expenses annually. |
Schectman, 2002 (80) | Cross-sectional | Examined relationship between adherence to drug therapy and DM metabolic control | 810 | Low socioeconomic adults with T2DM receiving oral diabetes medication from clinic pharmacy | University of Virginia Health Systems primary care clinic | Adherence to medication in T2DM patients was strongly associated with metabolic control in indigent populations. |
Lairson, 2008 (62) | Intervention | Evaluate the effect of a disease management program on adherence with recommended testes, health outcomes and health care expenditures for patients with T2DM | 870 | Adult patients with T2DM | Kelsey-Seybold Clinic Houston , Texas | The intervention increased compliance with testing for A1c and decreased A1c value and the percent of patients with A1c ≥9.5. Point estimates showed small reduction in health care cost, with cost of office visits showing the only significance (.10). |
Grant, 2005 (47) | Cross sectional | To assess differences in demographics, self-care behaviors, and diabetes-related risk factor control by frequency of Internet use | 909 | Individuals with type 2 diabetes attending primary care clinics | Hospital-based internal medicine clinic practice in Boston, MA | Those who were internet users were not statistically significant nor more likely to have an HbA1c >7% [OR 1.0 95% CI 0.7-1.4] and blood pressure <130/80mmHg [1.3 95% CI 0.9-2.0] but there was a internet users were statistically more likely to have an LDL <100mg/dl [OR 0.7 95% CI 0.5-0.99] |
Salvo, 2012 (79) | Retrospective cohort study comparing pharmacist-managed insulin to standard care Duration: 24 months |
To assess the impact of pharmacist-managed insulin titration program compared to standard medical care on glycemic control and preventive care measures in an indigent population with diabetes | 126 | Low income patients with type 1 or type 2 diabetes using insulin therapy | St. Louis County Department of Health | At the end of the study the intervention group showed a significant difference in HbA1c compared to standard of care (−1.3% vs. −0.18%, p=0.001) |
Camacho, 2002 (34) | Cross sectional | Describe and find correlates of health-related quality of life | 249 | Underserved, low-income patients in North Carolina with type 1 or type 2 diabetes | Public and private, non-profit, health organizations | There was an inverse relationship between glycemic control and energy and mobility (β=−4.58, p<0.05); LDL control predicted better mental health ((β=4.54, p<0.01); blood pressure was inversely associated with sexual function (β=−5.89, p<0.01) |
Hills-Briggs, 2005 (52) | Randomized controlled trial Duration: 24 months |
Examine medication adherence, association of medication adherence with HbA1c, and the association of medication adherence with sociodemographic and psychosocial variables | 181 | African Americans with type 2 diabetes who reside in an impoverished sociodemographic environment | Johns Hopkins-affiliated primary care clinics | Individuals in this impoverished environment tended to have higher HbA1c due to behaviors of carelessness in taking medications and stopping medications because of feeling better. No p-value reported. |
Kollannoor-Samuel, 2011 (61) | Randomized controlled, longitudinal study | Identify demographic, socioeconomic, acculturation, lifestyle, sleeping patterns, and biomedical determinants of fasting plasma glucose and glycosylated hemoglobin | 211 | Latino adults with type 2 diabetes who were recruited from a metabolic syndrome clinic at Hartford Hospital | Home interview | Those who had a lower income were more likely (OR 10.4, 95% CI 1.54-69.30) to have higher HbA1c |
Kogan, 2009 (60) | Cross sectional path analysis | Test the hypothesis that financial distress, community disadvantage and educational attainment contribute to poor glycemic control indirectly via depressive symptoms among rural African Americans | 192 | African Americans with type 2 diabetes | Rural counties in central Georgia | Structural equation modeling analyses confirmed hypothesis that financial distress, community disadvantage and educational attainment demonstrate significant indirect effects on HbA1c via depressive symptoms |
Hill-Briggs, 2011 (53) | Randomized controlled trial Compare intensive and condensed program format | Determine feasibility, acceptability and effect of problem-based diabetes self-management training in low socioeconomic, low literacy population | 52 | Adult (25+) African Americans with type 2 diabetes | Urban African Americans in Baltimore, MD | Intensive problem-solving based program led to improvements in HbA1c (−0.72%) above that of condensed format (p=0.02). Showed clinically significant changes for those with suboptimal baseline measures in HbA1c, blood pressure, and LDL. |
Khan, 2011 (57) | Randomized controlled trial Computer multimedia education program vs educational brochure (control) |
Evaluate the impact of a waiting room-administered, low-literacy, computer multimedia diabetes education program on patient self-management and provider intensification therapy | 129 | Uninsured adults with type 2 diabetes | County clinic in Chicago, IL | There was a decrease in HbA1c when comparing the intervention and control groups (−1.5% vs −0.8%, p=0.06) |