Table 3:
Summary of articles focused on Social and Community Context
Author/Year | Study Design | Objective | Number of Participants |
Sample population |
Setting | Impact on Outcome |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Knight, 2008 (59) | Cross-sectional | Using screening by student pharmacists to identify depression, undiagnosed and under treated in patients with T2DM and to understand influence on DM control | 45 | Adults with primarily T2DM seen urban primary care clinic | 5 Cincinnati Health Department Clinics | No significant differences were found on mean A1c or fasting blood glucose between depressed and non-depressed individuals. |
Egede, 2010 (40) | Cross sectional | Assess differences in metabolic control and health-related quality of life among depressed and non-depressed adults in indigent population with type 2 diabetes | 201 | Low income adults with type 2 diabetes | Academic medical center in Southeastern United States | Depressed compared to non-depressed patients had a lower SF-12 PCS (36.1 vs. 39.0, p≤0.001) and MCS (41.6 vs. 46.8, p≤0.001); there was no significant difference in LDL and HbA1c between these two groups |
Moayad, 2006 (68) | Cross-sectional | Evaluate effect of family cohesiveness, acculturation, socioeconomic position, and CVD risk factors on DM severity | 275 (n=193 for patients deemed to have severe DM) | Mexican Americans with T2DM | Two medical clinics in north Fort Worth, TX for 2 years | HbA1c used to define disease severity (≥7=severe; <7=non-severe). Acculturation and family cohesiveness were not statistically associated with disease severity. Factors associated with disease severity: receiving food stamps (adjusted OR 3.8, 95% CI 1.5-9.6), having spent childhood in Mexico (adjusted OR 1.2, 95% CI 1.1-1.4), and smoking status (adjusted OR 3.2, 95% CI 1.1-10.0). |
Venkatesh, 2013 (86) | Mixed methods | Examine impact of acculturation on glycemic control | 30 | 1st generation Asian Indian (AI) adults with T2DM | Participants recruited from community (AI organizations, stores, restaurants, and listservs) in a mid-western state (MI) | Statistical difference in mean HbA1c (6.4±0.3 intervention, vs. 7.9±0.7 control; p<.01). Interactions among acculturation and annual household income, BMI, and DM duration significantly predicted higher HbA1c levels (R2 change=.368; F change=4.21; p=.02). |
Osborne, 2010 (70) | Cross-sectional | To examine the relationship between health literacy, determinants of DM self-care and glycemic control | 130 | Adults with T2DM seen in local primary care clinic | University Internal Medicine Clinic of the Medical University of South Carolina | Glycemic control and DM self-care was indirectly effected by health literacy (r= −0.01), (r= −0.07) |
Okuson, 2002 (69) | Secondary data analysis using the Third National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES III) | To compare racial/ethnic differences in diabetes awareness, treatment and glycemic control between NHW, NHB, and HW Americans | 6334 | Individuals who were NHW, NHB, or HW, ≥40 years old and had data available for weight, height, waist circumference, had health insurance, and HbA1c values | N/A | NHB and HW men were 0.73 [CI 0.45-1.17] and 0.45 [95% 0.29-0.71] less likely than NHW to have poor glycemic control than NHW men; NHB and HW women were 0.39 [95% CI 0.26-0.61] and 0.43 [0.26-0.70] less likely than NHW to have poor glycemic control than NHW women |
Toobert, 2007 (85) | Randomized controlled trial-intervention Mediterranean Lifestyle Program Duration: 24 months |
To examine the long-term effects of interactions between lifestyle behaviors, psychosocial factors and social environment | 270 | Postmenopausal women with type 2 diabetes | N/A | Quality of life was not statistically significant between the intervention and usual care groups (F=3.45, p<0.1); the direct and indirect cost of the intervention group was $409,165 compared to $309,302 for the usual care group |
Kirk, 2011 (58) | Chart review and cross-sectional survey | Examine the relationship between patient variables and glycemic control (HbA1c <7%) in a cohort of family medicine patients with type 2 diabetes | 669 | Individuals were selected if their chart had an International Classification of Diseases, Ninth Revision, Clinical Modification codes for diabetes | University-based family medicine teaching site | Of the study population, 43.2% had an HbA1c > 7%, 36.3% had an LDL < 100 mg/dl, 44.7% had a systolic blood pressure <130mmHg, and 69.1% had a diastolic blood pressure < 80mmHg |
Fortmann, 2011 (42) | Cross-sectional path analysis | Investigate value of support resources in disease management | 208 | Latinos with type 2 diabetes | Low-income serving community clinics in San Diego | Path analyses revealed that greater support resources were linked to better self-management (p<0.001) and less depression (p<0.01). Once these factors were statistically controlled the pathway from support resources to HbA1c was markedly reduced (p=0.57) |
Gary, 2000 (43) | Cross-sectional | Determine prevalence of depressive symptoms and relationship between depressive symptoms and metabolic control | 183 | African American adults aged 35-75 | Two primary care clinics in Baltimore, MD | Depressive symptoms are marginally associated with suboptimal levels of HbA1c (p=0.104), blood pressure (p=0.073), and LDL (p=0.176), and significantly associated with suboptimal levels of total cholesterol and triglycerides (p<0.05). |
Bird, 2007 (31) | Cross-sectional | Assess gender differences in quality of care | 4,054 | Enrollees in commercial and Medicare health plans | National sample | Gender differences found in variety of quality of care measures. Statistically significant differences in intermediate outcomes for diabetics includes lipid control for Medicare enrollees (p<0.01) and commercial enrollees (p<0.01), and blood pressure control for commercial enrollees (p<0.05). Relative risk for women relative to men for LDL was 0.84. |
Chiu, 2010 (36) | Longitudinal cohort | Longitudinal association between depressive symptoms and glycemic control and extent to which it is explained by health behaviors | 998 | Adults with diabetes | National sample from Health and Retirement Study | Adults with higher levels of depressive symptoms at baseline showed higher HbA1c levels at 5 year follow-up. Health behaviors account for 13% of link. |
Culica, 2007 (37) | Quasi-experimental | Evaluate cost and impact of educational model delivered to predominantly Spanish speaking Mexican American population with type 2 diabetes | 162 | Adults diagnosed with diabetes and no advanced complications | Clinic in Dallas, TX | Change in HbA1c at 6 mo was not significant, but change from baseline at 12 mo was significant (p<0.01). Blood pressure did not change at 6 or 12 mo. |
Hayes, 2000 (50) | Prospective cohort within trial to assess provider adherence to diabetes management protocol | Examine applicability and relationship of locus of control to glycemic control in low-literacy, economically deprived population | 312 | African Americans with type 2 diabetes referred to diabetes unit of public hospital | Urban public hospital in Georgia | No significant association between locus of control and baseline HbA1c. Significant relationship between belief in chance and glycemic control at 6-mo follow up (p<0.05) and change in HbA1c (p<0.05). Patients with stronger believe in change had higher HbA1c levels and less change in HbA1c. |
Hernandez-Tejada, 2012 (51) | Cross-sectional | Examine relationship between perceived control of diabetes and qualify of life | 188 | Adults with type 2 diabetes having been seen in clinic | Low-income clinic in Southeast US | Positive association between perceived control and quality of life (p<0.05) when controlling for sociodemographics and comorbidity. |
Kacerovsky-Bielesz, 2009 (56) | Cross-sectional | Examine sex-specific differences and influences of social and psychological factors on glucometabolic control. | 257 | Adults ages 40-80 diagnosed with diabetes and seen at diabetes outpatient clinic at least twice in 6-mo | Metropolitan diabetes outpatient clinic | Mean HbA1c did not differ between genders. Variables predicting high HbA1c differed by gender. For women: pain (p=0.003), social isolation (p=0.008), internal control (p=0.039), external control (p=0.019), and depressive coping (p=0.031). For men: emotional support (p=0.007), satisfaction with support (p=0.054), and instrumental support p=0.066) |
Wexler, 2006 (89) | Cross-sectional | Assess impact of medical comorbidities, depression, and treatment intensity on quality of life | 909 | Adults diagnosed with diabetes with continuous care | Two outpatient primary care clinics and hospital based primary care practice in Massachusetts | Emotion, pain and impaired vision were predominant drivers of overall health utility. Patients with depression had the lowest quality of life (p<0.0001) and differed by comorbidity. After adjustment the utility penalty diminished to some degree. Presence of depression was strongest correlate in multivariate model, decreasing utility by 0.37. |