Table 2. Consonance Models Evaluated in the Present Work.

Reference	Original name	Input	Implementation
Note. “Reference” identifies the literature where the model or relevant software package was originally presented. “Original name” corresponds to the name of the model (or corresponding psychological feature) in the reference literature. “Input” describes the input format for the model implementations used in this paper. “Implementation” describes the software used for each model implementation, with “incon” referring to the incon package that accompanies this paper, and “Essentia” and “MIRtoolbox” corresponding to the software presented in Bogdanov et al. (2013) and Lartillot et al. (2008) respectively. Terms in parentheses identify the low-level R packages that underpin the incon package, and that provide extended access to individual models.
Periodicity/harmonicity
Gill and Purves (2009)	Percentage similarity	Symbolic	incon (bowl18)
Harrison and Pearce (2018)	Harmonicity	Symbolic	incon (har18)
Milne (2013)	Harmonicity	Symbolic	incon (har18)
Parncutt (1988)	Root ambiguity	Symbolic	incon (parn88)
Parncutt and Strasburger (1994)	Complex sonorousness	Symbolic	incon (parn94)
Stolzenburg (2015)	Smoothed relative periodicity	Symbolic	incon (stolz15)
Lartillot, Toiviainen, and Eerola (2008)	Inharmonicity	Audio	MIRtoolbox
Interference
Bowling, Purves, and Gill (2018)	Absolute frequency intervals	Symbolic	incon (bowl18)
Huron (1994)	Aggregate dyadic consonance	Symbolic	incon
Hutchinson and Knopoff (1978)	Dissonance	Symbolic	incon (dycon)
Parncutt and Strasburger (1994)	Pure sonorousness	Symbolic	incon (parn94)
Sethares (1993)	Dissonance	Symbolic	incon (dycon)
Vassilakis (2001)	Roughness	Symbolic	incon (dycon)
Wang, Shen, Guo, Tang, and Hamade (2013)	Roughness	Symbolic	incon (wang13)
Bogdanov et al. (2013)	Dissonance	Audio	Essentia
Lartillot, Toiviainen, and Eerola (2008)	Roughness (after Sethares)	Audio	MIRtoolbox
Lartillot, Toiviainen, and Eerola (2008)	Roughness (after Vassilakis)	Audio	MIRtoolbox
Weisser and Lartillot (2013)	Roughess (after Sethares)	Audio	MIRtoolbox
Culture
Johnson-Laird, Kang, and Leong (2012)	Tonal dissonance	Symbolic	incon (jl12)
This paper	Corpus dissonance	Symbolic	incon (corpdiss)