Skip to main content
. 2014 Apr 14;2014(4):CD000227. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD000227.pub4

4. Baseline 25‐hydroxy vitamin D in intervention and control groups.

Study ID 25(OH)D nmol/L
Aloia 1988 Intervention 54.8 (SD 17.8); Control 66.5 (SD 29.3)
Arthur 1990 Intervention 30 (SD 7.5); Control 52.5 (SD 22.5)* (Considerable difference between intervention and control)
Avenell 2004 N/A
Bischoff 2003 Intervention 30.8 (interquartile range 23‐55); Control 29 (interquartile range 23‐55)
Bolton‐Smith 2007 Intervention 62.5 (SD 15.5); Control 57 (15.3)
Burleigh 2007 Intervention 21.7 (SD 7.1); Control 24.7 (SD 10.0)
Caniggia 1984 N/A
Chapuy 1992 Intervention 40.0 (SD 27.5); Control 32.5 (SD 22.5) subgroups
Chapuy 2002 Intervention 21.3 (SD 13.3), 22.5 (SD 16.5); Control 22.8 (SD 17.3)
Dawson‐Hughes 1997 Intervention 82.5 (SD 40.8) men, 71.8 (SD 33.3) women; Control 84.0 (SD 31.8) men, 61.3 (SD 25.8) women
Dukas 2004 Intervention 98.8 (SD 30.0); Control 97.8 (SD 27.3)*
Ebeling 2001 Intervention 91 (SD 42); Control 86 (27)
Falch 1987 N/A
Flicker 2005 Intervention 61% in 25‐40 range; Control 54% in 25‐40 range
Gallagher 1989 N/A
Gallagher 1990 N/A
Gallagher 2001 Intervention 78.0 (SD 21.6); Control 80.5 (SD 27.4)
Garay Lillo 1997 Intervention 58.3 (SD 46.3); Control 64.8 (SD 51.3) subgroups
Geusens 1986 N/A
Glendenning 2012 65.8 (SD 22.7) combined intervention and control subgroup
Gorai 1999 N/A
Harwood 2004 Intervention 28 (range 10‐67), 30 (range 12‐85), 29 (range 6‐75); Control 30 (range 12‐64)
Hayashi 1992 N/A
Inkovaara 1983 N/A
Ishida 2004 (retracted) N/A
Janssen 2010 Vitamin D and calcium 32.6 (SD 11.6); Placebo and calcium 34.3 (SD 11.5)
Komulainen 1998 N/A
Law 2006 Intervention 47 median (35‐102, 90th centile range) subgroup; no data for control group
Lips 1996 Intervention 27 (25th‐75th centile 19‐36); Control 26 (25th‐75th centile 19‐37) subgroups
Lyons 2007 N/A
Menczel 1994 N/A
Meyer 2002 Intervention 47 (SD 26); Control 51 (SD 33) subgroups
Mitri 2011 Vitamin D and calcium 56 (SE 4), Vitamin D and placebo 66 (SE 4), Calcium and placebo 63 (SE 5), Placebos 61 (SE 3)
Nakatsuka 1997 Intervention 58.4 (SD 24.5); Control 69.8 (SD 28.5)
Ones 2007 N/A
Orimo 1994 Intervention 58.0 (SD 22.5); Control 50.3 (SD 16.3)
OSTPRE‐FPS 2007 Intervention 50.0 (SD 18.7); Control 49.1 (SD 17.7) subgroups
Ott 1989 Intervention 66.8 (SD 31.5); Control 65.8 (SD 39.3)
Peacock 2000 Intervention 65.0 (SD 25) men, 57.5 (SD 33) women; Control 65.0 (SD 30) men, 60.0 (SD 30) women
Pfeifer 2000 Interventiion 25.7 (SD 13.6); Control 24.6 (SD 12.1)
Pfeifer 2009 Vitamin D and calcium 55 (SD 18); Calcium 54 (SD 18)
Porthouse 2005 N/A
Prince 2008 Intervention 45.2 (SD 12.5); Control 44.3 (SD 12.7)
RECORD 2005 Intervention 38.0 (SD 16.3); Control 39.5 (SD 14.8) subgroups*
Shiraki 1996 N/A
Smith 2007 Intervention 56.5; Control 62.2 subgroups
Tilyard 1992 N/A
Trivedi 2003 N/A
Ushiroyama 2001 N/A
Vital D Intervention 53 (interquartile range 40‐65); Control 45 (interquartile range 40‐57) subgroups
WHI 2006 46.0 (SD 22.6) subsequent hip fracture, 48.4 (SD 23.5) Controls, subgroups
Witham 2010 Intervention 20.5 (SD 8.9); Control 23.7 (SD 10.0)
Witham 2013 Intervention 44(SD 16); Control 45(SD 15)

* reported as D3
N/A: not available