Skip to main content
. 2002 Apr 22;2002(2):CD000560. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD000560

Stevens 1996.

Methods Randomisation: 'randomly assigned' 
 Allocation concealment; opaque sealed envelopes (B) 
 Exclusion after randomisation; yes 
 ITT: no
Participants Casualty attenders after road traffic accident, dog bite or assault 
 Exclusions: non English speakers, not physically fit to be interviewed; need immediate psychiatric referral, homeless, intoxicated
Interventions Comparison: debriefing versus questionnaires 
 Time between event and intervention; <24 hrs
Outcomes PTSD (DSM‐III). 
 BDI. Spielberger 
 IES
Notes Losses to follow up not by group. 
 PTSD and other psychiatric disorders grouped together 
 Intention to treat: no 
 Intervention standardised: yes
Risk of bias
Bias Authors' judgement Support for judgement
Allocation concealment? Unclear risk B ‐ Unclear

BDI: Beck Depression Inventory 
 IES; Impact of Events Scale 
 ITT: Intention to treat 
 HAD: Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale 
 PSS: Post‐traumatic Stress DIsorder Symptom Scale 
 PTSD: Post traumatic stress disorder 
 EPDS: Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Score 
 SF‐36: 36 Item Short‐form Health Survey