Skip to main content
. 2002 Apr 22;2002(2):CD000560. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD000560

Bordow 1979.

Methods Randomisation: First 30 non randomly assigned to waiting list control: Next 40 allocated by 'random preset order' to brief or extended intervention 
 Allocation concealment: not stated (B) 
 Exclusion after randomisation: no 
 ITT; yes (probably ‐ no formal data on follow up)
Participants Male inpatients after road traffic accidents
Interventions Comparison: 
 Extended (minimal emotional support (1 hr) + practical and social support (max 10 hrs) 
 versus Brief "minimal emotional support" (1hr) 
 Time between event and intervention: up to 1 wk
Outcomes Langer 22 Item 
 Work Adjustment 
 Traumatic Neurosis Symptoms 
 Pleasant and Unpleasant experiences 
 Health deterioration
Notes Trial of brief versus extended therapy (no randomly allocated control condition) 
 No standard deviations for continuous measures; no cut offs for categorical measures. Not included in meta analysis
Risk of bias
Bias Authors' judgement Support for judgement
Allocation concealment? High risk C ‐ Inadequate