Skip to main content
. 2020 Feb 21;15(2):e0228812. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0228812

Table 2. Benchmarking of p and q lag orders, implementation time, and the value of GOF statistic for the full-search and the proposed algorithm for Trials 1, 2, 4, and 5.

Trial Full-Search algorithm Proposed algorithm
Statistic p q Time
(sec)
Value p q Time
(sec)
Value
X1 X2 X1 X2
1 AIC 1 1 1 3.96 -247.3 1 1 1 1.64 -247.3
BIC 1 1 1 3.67 -255.8 1 1 1 1.66 -255.8
MASE 5 5 5 3.65 0.337 4 3 5 1.80 0.340
GMRAE 4 3 5 3.59 0.239 4 3 5 1.79 0.239
2 AIC 4 4 4 13.01 -727.6 4 3 4 3.13 -725.6
BIC 4 1 4 12.67 -677.1 4 1 4 4.71 -677.1
MASE 5 7 7 13.07 0.124 5 7 7 4.66 0.124
GMRAE 5 6 6 13.27 0.080 4 7 4 4.63 0.084
4 AIC 2 2 10 143.6 6413 1 1 10 15.69 6413
BIC 1 1 10 140.2 6515 1 1 10 29.83 6515
MASE 8 9 9 136.6 0.514 8 9 9 26.69 0.514
GMRAE 4 8 8 137.9 0.509 5 3 8 17.01 0.512
5 AIC 5 4 5 35.81 40397 5 4 5 13.87 40397
BIC 1 3 5 35.43 40509 1 3 5 13.62 40509
MASE 5 4 5 34.27 0.435 5 4 5 13.15 0.435
GMRAE 4 2 5 33.85 0.565 4 2 5 10.73 0.565