Table-2.
Summary of DEE-related GRIN2D variants and patient’s phenotypes
Patient-1 | Patient-2 | Patient-3 | Patient-4 | Patient-5 | Patient-6 | Patient-7 | Patient-8 | Patient-9 | Patient-10 | Patient-11 | Patient-12 | Patient-13 | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
GRIN2D variants (NM_000836) | c.1345G>A:p.(Asp449Asn) | c.1718C>T: p.(Ser573Phe) | c.1999G>A: p.(Val667Ile) | c.1999G>A:p.(Val667Ile) | c.1999G>A:p.(Val667Ile) | c.2008C>T: p.(Leu670Phe) | c.2008C>T: p.(Leu670Phe) | c.2023G>A: p.(Ala675Thr) | c.2033C>A: p.(Ala678Asp) | c.2043G>C:p.(Met681Ile) | c.2080A>C:p.(Ser694Arg) | c.3812C>T: p.(Ser1271Leu) | c.3937C>T: p.(Arg1313Trp) |
Variant location | ABD | pre-M1 | M3 | M3 | M3 | M3 | M3 | M3 | M3 | M3 | ABD | CTD | CTD |
Gender | male | female | male | female | female | male | Female | N/A | Female | male | female | male | female |
Age at onset | 3 days | 2mo | 9mo | 4mo | 2mo | < 1yo | 4mo | N/A | 3y, 5mo | 2yo | 2yo | 2mo | <1yo |
Seizure types and EEG | startling seizure; EEG: intermittent multifocal discharges at 15 mon old | focal motor to GTCS; EEG: slow background, multifocal spikes | atypical absence; EEG: bilateral central spikes; hypsarrhythmia | complex partial seizure; EEG: frequent spikes and waves during awake and hypsarrhythmia during sleep | generalized seizure; EEG: sharp and spike wave discharges | epileptic spasms; EEG: diffuse paroxysmal abnormalities | focal motor to GTCS; EEG: continuous hypsarrhythmia with bilateral synchrony | epileptic spasms; EEG: N/A | focal motor → GTCS; EEG: frequent multifocal spikes; runs of faster alpha activity, multifocal spikes | febrile convulsion, afebrile generalized or unilateral convulsions, myoclonic seizure; EEG: Frequent multifocal spikes and diffuse spwc and sharp waves | tonic seizures, atonic seizures, atypical absence; EEG: Diffuse spwc. Focal spikes. Continuous diffuse spwc during sleep | epileptic spasms, myoclonic jerks; EEG: modified hypsarrhythmia; sporadic focal epileptic activity, runs of faster beta activity | GTCS, focal clonic, myoclonic, epileptic spasms; EEG: frequent/almost continuous sharp-waves with high amplitude |
Developmental delay and other neurological features | no head control, no rolling over, no speech; hypotonia, hyperreflexia; Disturbed sleep pattern | walked at 2yo; poor eye contact, autistic behaviors | severe DD; mild hypotonia, dyskinetic and choreiform movements; cerebral visual impairment, oculomotor apraxia, changing tone, periodic breathing pattern | sitting alone at 3.5yo, walking with support at 3.5yo, speaking single words at 6.5yo; axial hypotonia, mild appendicular hypertonia; facial dysmorphisms, bilateral mild fifth finger clinodactyly, mild pes planus; poor sleep | rolling over at 9 mon old, unable to sit alone; truncal and orofacial hypotonia, appendicular hypertonia, athetoid limb movements, autistic features; microcephaly, severe pes planus | severe DD; severe hypotonia; cerebral visual impairment, feeding difficulties | severe DD; hypotonia, dyskinetic and choreiform movements; visual impairment with inconstant fixation | DD | walked at 2yo; single words at 2.5yo; hypotonia; poor eye contact, autistic behaviors | sitting alone at 18 mon old, DQ < 10 at 7 yo; myoclonus, ballismus, autism | Walking alone at 14 mon old, speaking two-word sentences at 36 mon old, IQ 64 at 7yo, full-scale IQ 58 at 11yo; ADHD | Severe DD; severe axial hypotonia, continuous movements; cerebral visual impairment, pyramidal signs with abnormal plantars (2yo), failure to thrive | severe; severe hypotonia, tetraplegia; wheelchair user, scoliosis, cerebral visual impairment, amaurosis, feeding difficulties |
Brain MRI | loss of white matter, thin corpus callosum at 7.5 mon old | Normal | mild cerebral atrophy | N/A | normal | cortical atrophy | mild cerebral atrophy | N/A | Normal | normal at 6yo | normal at 3yr | normal | mild cerebral atrophy |
Response to AEDs | PB, CZP, VPA: partially effective. CLB, Vit. B6: not effective | no formal therapy | seizure free on memantine, IVIG, oral steroids and Mg | Intractable, ACTH, LEV, Memantine, Mg, ketamine, pentobarbital, MDZ | intractable; seizure free on memantine, sultiame, lamotrigine, and valproic acid | no response | mild amelioration of EEG on steroids – no clinical overt seizures | no response | seizure free on VPA, LEV, and clonazepam | Intractable, VPA, CLB, LTG, LEV, LCM | ESM: effective for atonic seizures and atypical absence. CBZ, VPA, CZP: not effective | relatively controlled by VPA, TPM and ELF (in combination with VNS) | no response |
Functional consequences | N/A | ↑glu/D-serine potency, ↑Mg inhibition, ↓pH inhibition, ↓Popen, ↓current amplitude, ↓receptor cell surface expression | ↑glu/gly potency, ↓Mg/pH/zinc inhibition, ↑Popen, ↑deactivation tau, causes neuronal cell death, dendritic swelling | ↑glu/gly potency, ↓Mg/pH/zinc inhibition, ↑Popen, ↑deactivation tau, causes neuronal cell death, dendritic swelling | ↑glu/gly potency, ↓Mg/pH/zinc inhibition, ↑Popen, ↑deactivation tau, causes neuronal cell death, dendritic swelling | ↑glu/gly/D-serine potency, ↓pH inhibition, ↑Popen, ↑deactivation tau, ↑charge transfer, ↓receptor cell surface expression | ↑glu/gly/D-serine potency, ↓pH inhibition, ↑Popen, ↑deactivation tau, ↑charge transfer, ↓receptor cell surface expression | ↑glu/gly/D-serine potency, ↓pH inhibition, ↓current amplitude, ↓receptor cell surface expression | ↑glu/gly/D-serine potency, ↑Popen, ↓current amplitude, ↓receptor cell surface expression; a significant ↓ in neuronal viability | N/A | N/A | ↓gly potency, No effects on Mg/pH inhibition, no effects on Popen and current amplitude, ↓receptor cell surface expression | ↓gly potency, No effects on Mg/pH inhibition, no effects on Popen and current amplitude, ↓receptor cell surface expression |
Source | Tsuchida et a., 2018 | XiangWei et al., 2019 | XiangWei et al., 2019; Li et al., 2016 | Li et al., 2016 | Li et al., 2016; XiangWei et al., 2019 | XiangWei et al., 2019 | XiangWei et al., 2019 | XiangWei et al., 2019 | XiangWei et al., 2019 | Tsuchida et a., 2018 | Tsuchida et a., 2018 | XiangWei et al., 2019 | XiangWei et al., 2019 |
AED, anti-epileptic drug; DD, developmental delay; GTCS, generalized tonic clonic seizures; LEV, levetiracetam; NA, not available; TPM, topiramate; VGB, vigabatrin; VNS, vagal nerve stimulator; ELF, ethylloflazepate; VPA, valproate.