CRISPR/Cas9 |
|
Difficult to employ in primary cells, useful in only established cell lines
Difficult to employ in vivo
Difficult to select for phenotypes requiring multiple cooperating genetic alterations
|
Transposon |
Genome wide
Useful in loss and gain of function studies
Allows screens to be done in cell lines or primary cells in vivo
Useful for selection of traits requiring multiple cooperating mutations
Non-coding or regulatory regions of the genome can be identified
|
Bias for or against parts of the genome due to local hopping and insertion site preference
Some genes are unlikely to be activated by transposon insertion if first ATG is in exon 1
Some genes are unlikely to be inactivated due to their small size (e.g., microRNAs)
Does not induce the full spectrum of mutations found in human cancers (e.g., point mutations and translocations)
Transposon mutagenesis can create mutations not tagged by the transposon due to re-mobilization
|
Retroviruses |
Many have been isolated with various tissue tropisms
Can activate endogenous promoters by enhancement mechanisms
Do not require generation of new transgenic lines of mice
|
Tend to not induce loss of function mutations, relatively few tumor suppressor genes identified in screens
Systems generally found and not created, meaning there are no retroviruses useful for modeling many important types of cancer
Tissue tropisms limit usefulness and types of cancer that can be modeled
Generally, cells must be dividing for infection
Many retroviruses have severe strain-specific effects and limitations
|