Skip to main content
. 2020 Jan 31;20(3):785. doi: 10.3390/s20030785

Table 5.

Comparison with the stand-alone access control systems based on facial image recognition.

Criteria Saraf et al. [25] Boka et al. [26] Bakshsi et al. [27] Sagar et al. [28] Sajjad et al. [29] Proposed Method
Embedded H/W Raspberry Pi Raspberry Pi with the Intel Movidius Neural Compute Stick Arduino Uno Renesas board (RL78 G13) Raspberry Pi 3 model B, ARM Cortex-A53, 1.2 GHz processor, video Core IV GPU Cortex dual core CPU, 2.50 DMIPS/MHz per core
Camera Single camera Two cameras Single camera Single camera Raspberry Pi camera Single camera
Face detection Haar cascade method Haar-feature based approach N/A PCA, LDA, histogram equalization Viola Jones Method AdaBoost with LBP
Facial feature LBP histogram FaceNet Global feature with principal component analysis PCA, LDA, histogram equalization Bag of words with oriented FAST and rotated BRIEF Gaussian derivative filter-LBP histogram
Face identification N/A k-NN Euclidean Distance N/A Support vector machine Histogram intersection
Execution time N/A N/A N/A 10 sec for authentication 9 s for first 10 matches 190 ms per image
Overall accuracy N/A 99.60% accuracy on LFW dataset N/A 90.00% accuracy on own dataset 91.33% average accuracy on Face-95 dataset 95.00% true accept rate on own video stream dataset