Table 1.
ANS-HPA emphasis | Model example | Author/Key citation | Primary measures | Core contributions |
---|---|---|---|---|
SNS HPA | Allostasis/Allostatic Load | McEwen (1998, 2007, 2017) | EDA; PEP (SNS) Cortisol (HPA) | Allostasis—expected stress and stress recovery cycle that allows one to return to baseline Proposed four allostatic load (AL) patterns based upon variation in SNS activation or HPA inhibition. Identified AL patterns underly many disease processes via imbalances in the activation (SNS) and inhibition (HPA) wherein the onset of an adult diagnosis is related to long-term immune system wear and tear. |
PNS | Polyvagal Theory | Porges (2007); Porges et al. (1996) | RSA or HRV | Identified two PNS vagus nerve branches Offers sequential and hierarchical stages of activation from newer (ventral vagal) to older (dorsal vagal) High PNS activity through HRV measurement associated with better self-regulation and less stress over-reactivity |
SNS and PNS | Modes of Autonomic Control | Berntson et al. (1991) Salomon et al. (2000) and Brush et al. (2019) | PEP and HRV PEP and RSA | Proposed nine modes of autonomic control from differing SNS and PNS dynamics—coupled, reciprocal, and uncoupled patterns Found four arousal profile patterns paralleling some patterns within the doctrine of autonomic control—Coactivation and co-inhibition, Reciprocal sympathetic, Reciprocal parasympathetic |
SNS and PNS SNS, PNS, and HPA-axis | Adaptive Calibration Model | Del Giudice et al. (2012); Quas et al. (2014) | EDA and RSA PEP, RSA, Cortisol | Originally proposed four patterns of SNS/PNS activity (Sensitive; Buffered; Vigilant; Unemotional) Found six arousal profile patterns in the multi-site study; Moderate reactivity (most common); Parasympathetic-specific reactivity; Anticipatory arousal; Multisystem reactivity; HPA-specific reactivity; Under-aroused |
SNS, Sympathetic nervous system; PNS, Parasympathetic nervous system; HPA-axis, Hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis; EDA, Electrodermal activity; HRV, Heart-rate variability; RSA, Respiratory sinus arrhythmia; PEP, Pre-ejection period.