Skip to main content
. 2020 Jan 20;10(1):e018041. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2017-018041

Table 1.

Qualitative data pre-IPE for the intervention and control groups: awareness of roles, expertise and responsibilities; nursing and medical students’ concerns about IPE; curriculum topics

Qualitative data
Pre-IPE
Intervention group Control group
Nursing students Medical students Medical students
Role
(of the ‘other’)
Doctor:
  • Diagnosis and treatment of the patient

Nurse:
  • Provides practical care

  • Provides support for the patient

Nurse:
  • Provides practical care

  • Communicates patients’ issues

  • Implements medical plans and working with doctors

Expertise Doctor:
  • Clinical knowledge

Nurse:
  • Patient care and monitoring

  • Medical knowledge

  • Safeguarding

  • Patient comfort

  • Patient concerns

Nurse:
  • Knowledge of patient needs

  • Practical care and management

  • Communication skills

Concerns about IPE Concerns:
  • To have inadequate knowledge

  • Being undermined

  • Being intimidated

  • Judged to be inferior

  • Not being taken seriously by medical students

  • Anticipation of a hierarchy within the group


Example comments:
‘Nervous I will not have enough clinical knowledge to contribute effectively and they will judge’
‘Personally I am intimidated learning alongside medical students’
Concerns:
  • Tailoring learning to both student groups and its effectiveness

  • Groups will have very different learning objectives, expectations and barriers

  • Appearing proud or arrogant to their nursing student colleagues


Example comments:
‘We need to learn different things’
‘Appearing arrogant, pretentious, condescending, proud’
Similar results to medical students in the intervention group
Curriculum topics
  • Communication

  • Ethics

  • Case-based teaching

  • Teamwork

  • Clinical skills

  • Assessment and management of the acutely unwell patient

  • Communication

  • Ethics

  • Case-based teaching

  • Assessment and management of the acutely unwell patient

  • Communication

  • Assessment and management of the complex patients and situations

IPE, interprofessional education.