Skip to main content
. 2020 Feb 27;2020(2):CD012277. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD012277.pub3
Study Reason for exclusion
Adel 2013 Wrong study design
Alves 2014 Wrong intervention
Alves 2014a Wrong intervention
Anderson 2014 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Ann 2012 Wrong patient population
Anon 2007 Nature of intervention unclear
Anon 2007a Nature of intervention unclear
Apostolo 2014 Wrong patient population
Baglio 2011 Nature of intervention unclear
Ball 2002 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Ball 2002a Duplicate
Ball 2006 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Ball 2013 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Ballesteros 2014 Duplicate
Ballesteros 2014a Duplicate
Ballesteros 2015 Duplicate
Ballesteros 2015a Duplicate
Ballesteros 2017 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Bamidis 2015 Wrong study design
Baniqued 2014 Adult population
Baniqued 2015 Younger than 30 years of age
Barban 2012 Duplicate
Barban 2016 Wrong study design: cross‐over trial that reported outcome data only at the end of trial, after cross‐over had taken place
Barbosa 2015 Wrong intervention
Barcelos 2015 Wrong intervention
Barnes 2006 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Barnes 2009 Duplicate
Barnes 2013 Wrong patient population
Basak 2016 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Beck 2013 Wrong intervention
Belchior 2007 Wrong outcomes
Belchior 2008 Wrong outcomes
Belleville 2006 Wrong intervention
Belleville 2014 Wrong outcomes
Berry 2010 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Bier 2015 Wrong study design
Binder 2016 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Bittner 2013 Wrong study design
Borella 2010 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Borella 2013 Wrong intervention
Borella 2014 Duplicate
Borella 2017 Wrong intervention
Boripuntakul 2012 Wrong intervention
Borness 2013 Wrong patient population
Bottiroli 2009 Duplicate
Bottiroli 2009a Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Bozoki 2013 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Brehmer 2012 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Brum 2013 Duplicate
Buitenweg 2017 Wrong intervention
Buiza 2008 Wrong intervention
Bureš 2016 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Buschert 2011 Wrong intervention
Buschert 2011a Duplicate
Buschert 2012 Wrong intervention
Buschert 2012a Duplicate
Buschkuehl 2008 Wrong design. Not an RCT. Quote: "pseudorandomly assigned to either the experimental or the control group. Both groups were matched as closely as possible according to gender, age, body weight, and selected physical performance measures"
Calkins 2011 Wrong intervention
Cammarata 2011 No outcome given
Cancela 2015 Wrong patient population
Candela 2015 Wrong intervention
Cantarella 2017 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Cao 2016 Wrong route of administration
Carretti 2013 Wrong intervention
Casutt 2014 Wrong outcomes
Chapman 2015 Wrong intervention
Chapman 2016 Wrong intervention
Chapman 2017 Wrong intervention
Cheng 2012 Wrong intervention
Cheng 2018 Wrong patient population
Cho 2002 Younger than 30 years of age
Cleverley 2012 Wrong intervention
Cohen‐Mansfield 2014 Wrong intervention
Cohen‐Mansfield 2014a Wrong intervention
Cohen‐Mansfield 2015 Wrong intervention
Cohen‐Mansfield 2015a Duplicate
Combourieu 2014 Wrong outcomes
Corbett 2015 Wrong patient population
Costa 2015 Wrong patient population
Danassi 2015 Duplicate
Dannhauser 2014 Wrong study design
de Almondes 2017 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
de Macedo 2015 Wrong outcomes
De Vreesse 1996 Wrong intervention
Diamond 2015 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Dittmann‐Kohli 1991 Wrong intervention
Djabelkhir 2017 Wrong patient population
Duncan 2009 Wrong intervention
Dwolatzky 2005 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Eckroth‐Bucher 2009 Wrong patient population
Edwards 2005 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Edwards 2011 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Edwards 2015 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Edwards 2015a Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Efthymiou 2011 Wrong comparator
Engvig 2014 Wrong study design
Fabre 2002 Wrong intervention
Faille 2007 Nature of intervention unclear
Fairchild 2010 Wrong intervention
Feng 2013 Wrong intervention
Feng 2015 Wrong intervention
Feng 2017 Wrong patient population
Fiatarone Singh 2014 Wrong patient population
Finn 2011 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Finn 2015 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Finn 2015a Duplicate
Flak 2013 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Flak 2014 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Flak 2014a Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Flak 2016 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Foerster 2009 No outcome given
Forloni 2012 No outcome given
Forster 2011 Wrong intervention
Fortman 2013 Wrong comparator
Gagnon 2012 Wrong study design
Gagnon 2012a Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Gaitan 2013 Wrong patient population
Gajewski 2012 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Gajewski 2017 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Garcia‐Campuzano 2013 Nature of intervention unclear
Gates 2011 Study protocol
Gill 2016 Wrong intervention
Gillette 2009 No outcome given
Giovannini 2015 No outcome given
Giuli 2016 Wrong intervention
Giuli 2017 Wrong intervention
Golino 2017 Wrong intervention
Gooding 2016 Wrong patient population
Haesner 2015 Wrong study design
Haesner 2015a Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Haimov 2013 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Haimov 2013a Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Haimov 2013b Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Haimov 2013c Duplicate
Haimov 2013d Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Haimov 2014 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Haimov 2014a Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Hardy 2015 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Hausmann 2012 Wrong intervention
Hayashi 2012 Wrong intervention
Hayslip B Jr 2016 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Heinzel 2014 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Herrera 2012 Wrong patient population
Hudak 2013 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Hughes 2014 Wrong population: participants with mild cognitive impairment
Hötting 2013 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Ignjatovic 2015 Younger than 30 years of age
Irigaray 2012 Wrong intervention
Israel 1997 Nature of intervention unclear
ISRCTN70130279 Wrong intervention
Jackson 2012 Nature of intervention unclear
Jansen 2012 Wrong intervention
Jean 2010 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Jeong 2016 Wrong intervention
Jobe 2001 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Jones 2013 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Kampanaros 2010 Wrong intervention
Kholin 2010 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Kim 2012 Wrong outcomes
Kim 2013 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Kim 2013a Wrong outcomes
Kim 2015 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Kim 2015a Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Kim 2015b Duplicate
Kivipelto 2014 Wrong intervention
Klusmann 2009 Duplicate
Klusmann 2010a Duplicate
Klusmann 2011 Younger than 30 years of age
Kudelka 2014 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Kwak 2015 Natue of intervention unclear
Kwak 2017 Nature of intervention unclear
Kwok 2013 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Kwok 2013a Wrong patient population
Lampit 2013 Wrong study design
Lavretsky 2016 Nature of intervention unclear
Law 2014 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Law 2014a Duplicate
Lee 2013 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Lee 2013a Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Lee 2013b Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Lee 2014 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Lee 2015 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
León 2015 Wrong comparator
Li 2010 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Linde 2014 Nature of intervention unclear
Mace 2015 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Mahncke 2006 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Maillot 2012 Wrong intervention. RCT meeting all inclusion criteria but those for the intervention: exergames, which we considered to be a combined intervention of physical exercise and computerised cognitive training; persons in the control group received no intervention
Man 2012 Wrong comparator
Mann 2012 Wrong patient population
Margrett 2006 Wrong patient population
Mayas 2014 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
McAvinue 2013 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
McDaniel 2014 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
McDougall 2012 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Middleton 2012 Wrong intervention
Miller 2013 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Mohs 1998 Wrong intervention
Mombelli 2012 No outcome given
Moon 2013 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Mowszowski 2014 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Mowszowski 2014a Duplicate
Mozolic 2010 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Mozolic 2011 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Muller 2011 Nature of intervention unclear
Na 2013 Duplicate
Na 2014 Nature of intervention unclear
Naismith 2014 Duplicate
Navarro 2006 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
NCT02417558 2015 Nature of intervention unclear
NCT02462135 2014 No outcome given
NCT02480738 2012 No outcome given
NCT02512627 2015 No outcome given
NCT02747784 2016 Wrong patient population
NCT02774083 2015 Wrong comparator
NCT02785315 2016 Wrong intervention
NCT02808676 2016 Wrong intervention
Neely 2013 Nature of intervention unclear
Ng 2015 Wrong intervention
Ngandu 2015 Wrong intervention
Ngandu 2015a Wrong intervention
Nishiguchi 2015 Wrong intervention
Nouchi 2012 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Nouchi 2013 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Nozawa 2015 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
O'Caoimh 2015 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Oei 2013 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Oliveira 2013 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Optale 2010 Wrong patient population
Otsuka 2015 Wrong study design
Park 2009 Nature of intervention unclear
Park 2014 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Payne 2012 Wrong intervention
Payne 2017 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Rahe 2015 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Rahe 2015a Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Rebok 2013 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Rebok 2014 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Redick 2013 Younger than 30 years of age
Requena 2016 Wrong intervention
Rizkalla 2015 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Rojas 2013 Wrong intervention
Rose 2015 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Rosen 2011 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Rozzini 2007 Wrong patient population
Ryu 2013 Wrong study design
Sakka 2015 Wrong study design
Santos 2011 Wrong comparator
Schoene 2015 Duplicate
Schoene 2015a Duplicate
Schumacher 2013 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Shah 2012 Wrong patient population
Shatil 2014 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Shatil 2014a Duplicate
Sisco 2013 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Slegers 2009 Wrong intervention
Smith 2009 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Smith‐Ray 2014 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Smith‐Ray 2015 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Smith‐Ray 2015a Duplicate
Solomon 2014 Wrong comparator
Song 2009 Wrong intervention
Stepankova 2014 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Stine‐Morrow 2014 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Strenziok 2013 Duplicate
Strenziok 2014 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Sturz 2011 Wrong patient population
Sturz 2011a Nature of intervention unclear
Sturz 2015 Duplicate
Styliadis 2015 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Styliadis 2015a Duplicate
Suo 2012 Wrong outcomes
Szelag 2012 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Talib 2008 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Tappen 2014 Wrong intervention
Tennstedt 2013 Study protocol
Tesky 2012 Wrong intervention
Tsai 2008 Wrong study design
Tsolaki 2013 Nature of intervention unclear
Tucker‐Drob 2009 Wrong study design
van den Berg 2016 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
van der Ploeg 2016 Wrong study design
Vance 2007 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Vidovich 2009 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Vidovich 2015 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Vidovich 2015a Duplicate
von Bastian 2013 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Wadley 2007 Wrong study design
Walton 2015 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Wang 2013 Wrong intervention
Weicker 2013 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Wild‐Wall 2012 Wrong outcomes
Williams 2014 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Willis 1986 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Willis 2006 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Willis 2006a Duplicate
Willis 2007 Duplicate
Willis 2013 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Wojtynska 2011 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Wolinsky 2006 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Wolinsky 2006a Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Wolinsky 2010 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Wolinsky 2010a Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Wolinsky 2013 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Wolinsky 2015 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Yam 2014 Wrong intervention
Yassuda 2015 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Yip 2012 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Yoonmi 2012 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Youn 2011 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Zelinski 2011 Wrong study design
Zelinski 2011a Intervention shorter than 12 weeks
Zhuang 2013 Wrong patient population
Zimmermann 2014 Intervention shorter than 12 weeks