Table 3.
Critical interpretive synthesis.
Adapted from Dixon-Woods et al. [18]
Although non-linear and iterative, critical interpretive synthesis could be understood to follow these steps | |
---|---|
Step | Sub-step |
1. Using a broad, provisional research question, undertake a literature search | |
2. Gather identified papers into a sampling frame | |
3. Iteratively select sources from the sample frame, review and extract data | (a) Sources are purposively selected from the sample frame using principles of theoretical sampling (e.g. contribution to research goal); fatally flawed studies are discarded |
(b) Extract data using the thematic method to develop codes for key arguments and phrases and theories; cluster codes into themes | |
(c) Continue theoretical sampling, data extraction and theme development until theoretical saturation | |
4. Synthesize arguments from the themes, integrating these with existing evidence |