Table 2.
Studies | Algorithm | Images used | Average DSCa | Patient number | Journal |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Deng et al. (10) | SVMb | DCE-MRIc | 0.862 | 120 | Contrast Media and Molecular Imaging, 2018 |
Song et al. (8) | Graph-based cosegmentation | PET | 0.761 | 2 | IEEE Transactions on Medical Imaging, 2013 |
Yang et al. (9) | MRFsd | PET, CT, MRI | 0.740 | 22 | Medical Physics, 2015 |
Stefano et al. (11) | AK-RWe | PET | 0.848 | 18 | Medical and Biological Engineering and Computing, 2017 |
Wang et al. (4) | CNNf | MRI | 0.725 | 15 | Neural Processing Letters, 2018 |
Ma et al. (12) | CNNs+3D graph cut | MRI | 0.851 | 30 | Experimental and Therapeutic Medicine, 2018 |
Men et al. (15) | DDNNg | CT | 0.716 | 230 | Frontiers in Oncology, 2017 |
Li et al. (16) | CNN | CE-MRI | 0.890 | 29 | Biomed Research International, 2018 |
Huang et al. (17) | CNN | PET-CT | 0.736 | 22 | Contrast Media and Molecular Imaging, 2018 |
Ma et al. (18) | C-CNNh | CT-MRI | 0.746 | 90 | Physics in Medicine and Biology, 2019 |
Proposed method | CNN | Dual-sequence MRI | 0.721 | 44 | – |
DSC, Dice similarity coefficient;
SVM, support vector machine;
DCE-MRI, dynamic contrast-enhanced magnetic resonance imaging;
MRFs, Markov random fields;
AK-RW, adaptive random walker with k-means;
CNN, convolutional neural network;
DDNN, deep deconvolutional neural network;
C-CNN, combined convolutional neural network.