Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2020 Oct 1.
Published in final edited form as: Complement Ther Med. 2019 Aug 16;46:172–179. doi: 10.1016/j.ctim.2019.08.009

Table 3.

Forest Plot of the Cumulative Weighted Mean Effects for Blood Pressure Based on Start Date of Data Collection.

Cumulative Statistics
Study Citation Outcome N Date Point SE Variance 95% CI Cumulative d+ (95% CI)
Lower Upper
Schneider et al. (1995) SBP 74 1989 0.9716 0.2501 0.0626 0.4814 1.4618 graphic file with name nihms-1558144-t0003.jpg
Kondwani et al. (2005) SBP 34 1992 0.3556 0.6414 0.4114 −0.9015 1.6126
Calderon (2000) SBP 71 1995 0.1503 0.4417 0.1951 −0.7155 1.0160
Schneider et al. (2012) SBP 183 1998 0.2349 0.2733 0.0747 −0.3008 0.7705
Paul-Labrador et al. (2006) SBP 84 1999 0.2715 0.2075 0.0430 −0.1351 0.6781
Schneider et al. (2005) SBP 98 1999 0.2636 0.1668 0.0278 −0.0633 0.5905
MM 0.2636 0.1668 0.0278 0.0633 0.5905
ML 0.2673 0.1547 0.0239 0.0358 0.5704
Schneider et al. (1995) DBP 74 1989 0.8427 0.2466 0.0608 0.3594 1.3260 graphic file with name nihms-1558144-t0004.jpg
Kondwani et al. (2005) DBP 34 1992 0.6326 0.2653 0.0704 0.1127 1.1525
Calderon (2000) DBP 71 1995 0.3134 0.3419 0.1169 −0.3567 0.9835
Schneider et al. (2012) DBP 183 1998 0.2904 0.2071 0.0429 −0.1154 0.6962
Paul-Labrador et al. (2006) DBP 84 1999 0.2429 0.1622 0.0263 −0.0751 0.5609
Schneider et al. (2005) DBP 98 1999 0.2837 0.1361 0.0185 0.0170 0.5504
MM 0.2837 0.1361 0.0185 0.0170 0.5504
ML 0.2848 0.1571 0.0247 0.0231 0.5926

Note. The cumulative weighted mean effect sizes are calculated using random-effects models with methods of moments (MM) or full information maximum likelihood (ML) to estimate the between-study variance. Weighted mean effect sizes (d+) are positive for differences that favor the transcendental meditation (TM) group relative to controls. Date refers to the year data collection commenced. d+, weighted mean effect size; SE, standard error; CI, confidence interval; SBP, systolic blood pressure; DBP, diastolic blood pressure.

The start and end dates for the study trial were not provided and therefore we used the start date of the study funding period.