Skip to main content
. 2020 Feb 28;15(2):e0229707. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0229707

Table 2. Outcome measures.

Outcome measure (subjects per group HAL/CONV) HAL CONV Between groups (p-value)
Independence in walking (FAC)
    FAC T1 (16/16) 0 [0;1] 0 [0;1] 1.000
    FAC T2 (16/16) 2 [1.25;3] 2.5 [1.25;3]
    FAC T3 (16/14) 4 [3;5] 4 [2.75;5]
    ΔT1-T2 (16/16) 2 [1;2.75] 2 [1;3] 0.926
    ΔT2-T3 (16/14) 2 [1;2] 1.5 [0.75;2.25] 0.473
    ΔT1-T3 (16/14) 4 [3;4.75] 4 [2.75;4] 0.728
Balance (BBS)
    BBS T1 (16/16) 8 [5.25;12.75] 8 [5.25;14.75] 0.696
    BBS T2 (16/16) 22 [10.25;40.25] 22.5 [11.5;35]
    BBS T3 (16/14) 45 [29.75;52] 45.5 [25.75;53.25]
    ΔT1-T2 (16/16) 8.5 [6;31.75] 14 [4.25;20] 0.780
    ΔT2-T3 (16/14) 15.5 [3;27.25] 18 [6.75;25.5] 0.886
    ΔT1-T3 (16/14) 34.5 [17.75;41,5] 32.5 [19.75;41.25] 0.918
Motor function (FMA-motor)
    FMA T1 (16/16) 7.5 [4;13.5] 7.5 [4;17.75] 0.590
    FMA T2 (16/16) 14 [5.25;21.5] 14.5 [4.25;27]
    FMA T3 (16/14) 21 [13.25;25.25] 15.5 [11;29.5]
    ΔT1-T2 (16/16) 3 [2;9.75] 1 [-0.75;6.75] 0.224
    ΔT2-T3 (16/14) 4 [2;7.5] 2 [0.75;9.25] 0.355
    ΔT1-T3 (16/14) 12 [5.5;15] 7 [3;17.25] 0.580
Activities of Daily Living (BI)
    BI T1 (16/16) 35 [30;50] 40 [35;45] 0.590
    BI T2 (16/16) 60 [42.5;65] 57.5 [45;65]
    BI T3 (16/14) 90 [71.25;98.75] 90 [62.5;96.25]
    ΔT1-T2 (16/16) 20 [15;28.75] 12.5 [10;25] 0.149
    ΔT2-T3 (16/14) 27.5 [11.25;38.75] 30 [17.5;35] 0.854
    ΔT1-T3 (16/14) 45 [40;58.75] 47.5 [28.75;55] 0.525
Walking speed/endurance (2MWT)
    2MWT T1 (16/16) 4 [0;7] 2 [0;13.625] 0.926
    2MWT T2 (16/16) 20.75 [8.5;44.75] 20.75 [7.25;60.25]
    2MWT T3 (16/14) 39.5 [26.5;108.125] 69.5 [21.875;137.125]
    ΔT1-T2 (16/16) 14.75 [8.375;38] 12.5 [7.125;51] 0.838
    ΔT2-T3 (16/14) 22.750 [8.25;50.875] 37 [11.375;79.625] 0.728
    ΔT1-T3 (16/14) 35.75 [26.5;101.125] 68.5 [21.5;121.625] 0.728

Values presented as median and inter-quartile range [IQR]. HAL: HAL training group; CONV: Conventional gait training group; FAC: Functional Ambulation Categories; BBS: Berg Balance Scale; FMA: Fugl-Meyer Assessment; BI: Barthel Index; 2MWT: 2 Minute Walk Test; T1: time point 1 (Baseline); T2: time point 2 (after intervention); T3: time point 3 (6 months post stroke); Δ: change. P-values according to the Mann-Whitney U-test.