Table 1.
Study | Pharmacological agent | Dose | Type of study | Follow-up | Outcome measures | Sig. change in outcome measure(s) | Quality assessment | Grade of evidence |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Bloch 2012 | DHEA | 100 mg/day | Double-blind placebo controlled RCT | 6 months | Total body Spinal Hip Femoral Neck |
NS | 1 | B |
DiVasta 2012 | DHEA OC: EE/levonorgestrel |
50 mg 20 μg/0.1 mg |
Double-blind placebo controlled RCT | 6, 12 and 18 months | Lumbar spine Hip Whole body |
Stabilising effect | 2 | B |
Fazeli 2014 | Teriparatide (TPt) | 20 μg/day SC | Double Blind RCT | 3 and 6 months | Posteroanterior spine Lateral Spine Hip Femoral neck |
Sig. (spinal only) | 1 | A |
Golden 2002 | OC: EE/progestin | 20–35 μg EE/day | Prospective observational study | 11.4–23.1 months | Lumbar spine Femoral neck |
NS | 2 | C |
Golden 2005 | Alendronate | 10 mg/day | Double-blind placebo controlled RCT | 3, 6, 9 months and 1 yr | Lumbar spine Femoral neck |
NS | 2 | B |
Gordon 1999 | DHEA | 50, 100, or 200 mg/day | Controlled trial | 3 month | Lumbar spine Total body Femoral neck |
NS | 2 | C |
Grinspoon 1996 | rhIGF1 | 100 or 30 μg/kg/day | Controlled trial | 6 days | OC PICP PYRX DPYRX NTX |
Sig increase in all markers (100 μg/day) Sig, increase in PICP only (30 μg/day) | 2 | B |
Grinspoon 2002 | rhIGF-1 EE with rhIGF-EE+ placebo |
30 μg/kg SC twice/day 35 μg/day + 30 μg/kg SC twice/day 35 μg/day |
Double-blind placebo controlled RCT | 12 weeks | Lateral spine BMD Hip BMD Femoral neck BMD Total body BMD |
NS | 2 | B |
Iketani 2003 | MED | 45 μg/day | Controlled trial | 0.9 yr | Lumbar spine | Stabilising effect |
2 | C |
Karlsson 2000 | Estrogen replacement therapy | Various | Retrospective cohort study | 4.3 yr (1–16 yr range) | Lumbar Spine Femoral neck |
NS | 2 | C |
Misra 2009 | RhIGF1 | 30–40 mcg/k twice daily | Double-blind placebo controlled RCT | 7–9 days | IGF1 P1NP CTX |
Sig. increase in IGF1 and P1NP | 1 | A |
Misra 2011 | Transdermal: 17b-estradiol with cyclic progesterone Oral: EE + progesterone | 100 mg/day 3.75 mg/7.5 mg/11.25 mg/day | Double-blind placebo controlled RCT | 18 months | Lumbar spine Hip |
Sig. | 1 | A |
Miller 2011 | Risedronate (R) Transdermal testosterone (T) Combination |
35 mg/week 150 μg/day R:35 mg/week T: 150 μg/day |
Double-blind placebo controlled RCT | 12 months | Spinal BMD Hip, and radius BMD Body composition |
Sig. (R) | 1 | A |
Miller 2004 | Risedronate | 5 mg/day | Controlled trial | 6 months, 9 months | Spinal BMD | Sig. | 1 | A |
Miller 2005 | Transdermal testosterone | 150 μg/300 μg/day | Double-blind placebo controlled RCT | 3 weeks | Spinal BMD | NS | 1 | B |
Munoz 2002 | OC: EE | 30 μg/day | Controlled trial | 12 months | Spinal BMD | NS | 2 | C |
Seeman 1992 | OC: Various | Various | Prospective observational study | 61 months ± 9% duration of illness | Spinal BMD Femoral Neck BMD |
Sig. (spinal) | 2 | C2 |
Shibli-Rahhal 2012 | Teriparatide (TPt) | 20 mcg/day | Case study | 2 yr | Lumbar spine Femoral neck |
Sig. | 2 | D |
Strokosch 2006 | OC: Norgestimate (NGM) OC: EE |
180–250 μg/day 35 μg/day |
Double-blind placebo controlled RCT | 13 consecutive 28 day cycles | Lumbar spine BMD |
NS | 1 | B |
Study characteristics of included studies in the systematic review. ‘Spinal’ refers to measurement of BMD at the lumbar spine. BMD = Bone Mineral Density, aBMD = areal Bone Mineral Density. (n) = number, SC = subcutaneous injection, NS = non-significant, Sig. = statistically significant (p < 0.05), AN = Anorexia Nervosa, HC = Healthy Controls, BMI = Body Mass Index, Tpt = teriparatide, EE = ethinyl estradiol, ERT = estrogen replacement therapy. NGM = Norgestimate, OC = oral contraceptives, MED = Menatetrenone.