Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2021 Mar 1.
Published in final edited form as: Psychol Aging. 2020 Feb 3;35(2):220–249. doi: 10.1037/pag0000442

Table 3.

Results for Overall Effect Size, and Effect Size Separated by Mental status, Training Modules and Transfer

g 95% CI k p Qw (df) I2
Overall
Overall Net Gain (g) 0.28 0.23–0.33 215 <0.01 1062.4 (214) 79.86%
Net Gain Effects Separated by Mental Status and Training Modules
Mental Status
 HA 0.28 0.22–0.34 161 <0.01 903 (160) 82.28%
 MCI 0.27 0.18–0.37 54 <0.01 159.4 (53) 66.75%
Training Modules
 Single-component 0.29 0.23–0.36 112 <0.01 465.86 (111) 76.17%
 Multi-component 0.26 0.18–0.33 103 <0.01 507.9 (102) 79.92%
Transfer
 Near 0.37 0.3–0.44 173 <0.01 1929.1 (172) 91.08%
 Far 0.22 0.16–0.27 141 <0.01 795.77 (140) 82.41%
Transfer by Training Modules
 Near: Single-component 0.36 0.27–0.45 90 <0.01 1045.7 (89) 91.49%
 Far: Single-component 0.2 0.12–0.29 70 <0.01 377.81 (69) 81.74%
 Near: Multi-component 0.38 0.26–0.51 83 <0.01 867.6 (82) 90.55%
 Far: Multi-component 0.23 0.15–0.30 71 <0.01 407.94 (70) 82.84%
Mental Status by Training Modules
 HA: Single-component 0.30.23–0.37 94 <0.01 519.86 (93) 84.03%
 HA: Multi-component 0.24 0.15–0.34 67 <0.01 373.3 (66) 82.32%
 MCI: Single-component 0.27 0.17–0.36 18 <0.05 22.61 (17) ** 24.81%
 MCI: Multi-component 0.29 0.18–0.4 36 <0.01 134.33 (35) 73.94%
Transfer by Mental Status
 Near: HA 0.38 0.14–0.47 139 <0.01 420.96 (138) 85.44%
 Far: HA 0.22 0.15–0.34 115 <0.01 402.88 (114) 82.34%
 Near: MCI 0.27 0.07–0.46 38 <0.05 166.23 (37) 76.92%
 Far: MCI 0.18 0.04–0.45 26 <0.01 134.33 (25) 73.94%

Note:

*

indicates significant between-group heterogeneity test at p<.05.

**

indicates non-significant within-group heterogeneity test at p<.05. HA=Healthy Aging. MCI=Mild Cognitive Impairment.