Table 1.
Study (author, year) | Exp # | Species | Age (wk) | Sex | Obesity model | Challenge | Observation period | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Type | GT/DC | Type | Strain | Route | Dose | ||||||
Single-strain bacteria models | |||||||||||
Hsu, 2007 | 1 | Mouse | 8–12 | F | Gen | ob/ob | S. pneumoniae | n/a | IT | 105 CFU | 10 d |
2 | Mouse | 8–12 | M | Gen | ob/ob/lep | S. pneumoniae | n/a | IT | 105 CFU | 10 d | |
Strandberg, 2009 | 3 | Mouse | 5–7 | M | Gen | ob/ob | S. aureus | n/a | IV | 5 × 107 CFU | 17 d |
4 | Mouse | 5–7 | M | DIO | HFD | S. aureus | n/a | IV | 5 × 107 CFU | 17 d | |
Mancuso, 2014 | 5 | Mouse | 16–18 | F | Gen | CPEF/F | S. pneumoniae | n/a | IT | 5 × 104 CFU | 10 d |
Svahn, 2015 | 6 | Mouse | 6 | M | DIO | HFDP | S. aureus | n/a | IV | 3.8–4.5 × 107 CFU | 17 d |
7 | Mouse | 6 | M | DIO | HFDS | S. aureus | n/a | IV | 3.8–4.5 × 107 CFU | 17 d | |
8 | Mouse | 6 | M | DIO | HFDS-HP | S. aureus | n/a | IV | 3.8–4.5 × 107 CFU | 17 d | |
9 | Mouse | 6 | M | DIO | HFDS-LP | S. aureus | n/a | IV | 3.8–4.5 × 107 CFU | 17 d | |
Svahn, 2016 | 10 | Mouse | 6 | M | DIO | HFDS | S. aureus | n/a | IV | 3–5.4 × 107 CFU | 17 d |
11 | Mouse | 6 | M | DIO | HFDw6 | S. aureus | n/a | IV | 3–5.4 × 107 CFU | 17 d | |
Wan, 2016 | 12 | Mouse | 3-4 | M | DIO | HFD | E. coli | n/a | IN | 109 CFU | 96 h |
13 | Mouse | 3-4 | M | DIO | HFD | E. coli | n/a | IN | 1010 CFU | 96 h | |
Cecal ligation and puncture models | |||||||||||
Tschop, 2010 | 14 | Mouse | 6–10 | M | Gen | ob/ob | Polymicrobial | n/a | IP | n/a | 240 h |
15 | Mouse | 6–10 | M | DIO | HFD | Polymicrobial | n/a | IP | n/a | 240 h | |
16 | Mouse | 6–10 | M | Gen | ob/ob | Polymicrobial | n/a | IP | n/a | 240 h | |
Kaplan, 2012 | 17 | Mouse | 6 | M | DIO | HFD | Polymicrobial | n/a | IP | n/a | 30 h |
Siegl, 2014 | 18 | Mouse | 19 | M | DIO | HFD | Polymicrobial | n/a | IP | n/a | 240 h |
Kaplan, 2016 | 19 | Mouse | 6 | M | DIO | HFD | Polymicrobial | n/a | IP | n/a | 48 h |
Lipopolysaccharide | |||||||||||
Fagioni, 1998 | 20 | Mouse | 5 | F | Gen | ob/ob | E. coli 055:B5 | n/a | IP | 30 μg | 7 d |
21 | Mouse | 5 | F | Gen | ob/ob | E. coli 055:B5 | n/a | IP | 100 μg | 7 d | |
22 | Mouse | 5 | F | Gen | ob/ob | E. coli 055:B5 | n/a | IP | 300 μg | 7 d | |
23 | Mouse | 5 | F | Gen | db/db | E. coli 055:B5 | n/a | IP | 30 μg | 7 d | |
24 | Mouse | 5 | F | Gen | db/db | E. coli 055:B5 | n/a | IP | 100 μg | 7 d | |
25 | Mouse | 5 | F | Gen | db/db | E. coli 055:B5 | n/a | IP | 300 μg | 7 d | |
Segersvard, 2003 | 26 | Rat | NR | M | DIO | HFD35 | E. coli | n/a | IP | 2 mg | 72 h |
27 | Rat | NR | M | DIO | HFD60 | E. coli | n/a | IP | 2 mg | 72 h | |
Suto, 2007 | 28 | Mouse | NR | F | Gen | B6AY12w | E. coli 0111-B4 | n/a | IP | 50 μg | 7 d |
29 | Mouse | NR | F | Gen | B6Ay12w | E. coli 0111-B4 | n/a | IP | 100 μg | 7 d | |
30 | Mouse | NR | F | Gen | B6-ob/ob | E. coli 0111-B4 | n/a | IP | 100 μg | 7 d | |
31 | Mouse | NR | F | Gen | B6Ay12w | E. coli 0111-B4 | n/a | IP | 200 μg | 7 d | |
32 | Mouse | NR | F | Gen | B6Ay10m | E. coli 0111-B4 | n/a | IP | 50 μg | 7 d | |
33 | Mouse | NR | F | Gen | B6Ay10m | E. coli 0111-B4 | n/a | IP | 100 μg | 7 d | |
Sakai, 2013 | 34 | Rat | 4 | M | DIO | HFD | E. coli 0111-B4 | n/a | IP | 10 mg/kg | 24 h |
Fujiwara, 2014 | 35 | Rat | 4 | M | DIO | HFD | E. coli 0111-B4 | n/a | IP | 10 mg/kg | 12 h |
36 | Rat | 4 | M | DIO | HFD | E. coli 0111-B4 | n/a | IP | 10 mg/kg | 12 h | |
Single-strain virus models | |||||||||||
Smith, 2007 | 37 | Mouse | NR | NR | DIO | HFD | H1N1 influenza A | A/PR8 | IN | 2 HG units | 10 d |
Easterbrook, 2011 | 38 | Mouse | 20 | M | DIO | HFD | H1N1 influenza A | CA/09 | IN | 2.5 × 105 pfu | 15 d |
39 | Mouse | 20 | M | DIO | HFD | H1N1 influenza A | NY312 | IN | 2.5 × 105 pfu | 15 d | |
40 | Mouse | 20 | M | DIO | HFD | H1N1 influenza A | Sw31 | IN | 50ul-SW31 | 15 d | |
Milner, 2013 | 41 | Mouse | NR | M | DIO | HFD-UP | H1N1 influenza A | A/PR8 | PO | 5.3 × 105 TCID50 | 13 d |
42 | Mouse | NR | M | DIO | HFD-P | H1N1 influenza A | A/PR8 | PO | 5.3 × 105TCID50 | 13 d | |
Radigan, 2014 | 43 | Mouse | 8–12 | NR | Gen | db/db | H1N1 influenza A | A/WSN/33 | IT | 500 pu | 14 d |
44 | Mouse | 8–12 | NR | Gen | db/db | H1N1 influenza A | A/WSN/33 | IT | 1500 pu | 14 d | |
O'Brien, 2015∗ | 45 | Mouse | 11 | M | DIO | HFD | H1N1 influenza A | CA/09∗ | IN | 1 × 105 TCID50 | 10 d |
46 | Mouse | 8 | M | Gen | ob/ob | H1N1 influenza A | CA/09 | IN | 1 × 105 TCID50 | 10 d | |
47 | Mouse | 11 | M | DIO | HFD | H3N2 influenza A | HK68 | IN | 6.3 × 105 TCID50 | 10 d | |
48 | Mouse | 8 | M | Gen | ob/ob | H3N2 influenza A | HK68 | IN | 6.3 × 105 TCID50 | 10 d | |
Milner, 2015 | 49 | Mouse | 14–16 | M | DIO | HFD | H1N1 influenza A | CA/09 | IN | 5.8 × 105 | 14 d |
50 | Mouse | 14–16 | M | DIO | HFD | H1N1 influenza A | CA/09 | IN | 1.3 × 103 | 14 d | |
51 | Mouse | 13–16 | M | Gen | LepRH-/- | H1N1 influenza A | CA/09 | IN | 5.8 × 105 | 14 d | |
52 | Mouse | 13–16 | F | Gen | LepRH-/- | H1N1 influenza A | CA/09 | IN | 5.8 × 105 | 14 d |
B6-ob/ob: leptin-deficient mice; B6Ay10m and 12m: 10- and 12-week-old agouti peptide positive hyperphagic mice; CPE: lack functional carboxypeptidase enzyme; db/db: leptin receptor-deficient mice; DC: diet composition; DIO: diet-induced obesity; Exp: experiment; F: female; Gen: genetic-induced obesity; GT: genotype; HFD35: 35% of the energy from fat; HFD60: 60% of the energy from fat; HFD: high-fat diet; HFD-P: primed with virus; HFD-UP: unprimed; HFDP: polyunsaturated; HFDS-HP: high protein-to-carbohydrate ratio; HFDS-LP: low protein-to-carbohydrate ratio; HFDS: saturated; HFDw6: omega-6 fatty acid rich; IN: intranasal; IP: intraperitoneal; IT: intubation; IV: intravenous; LepRH-/-: lack leptin receptor signaling in hypothalamic neurons; M: male; n/a: not applicable; ob/ob: leptin-deficient mice; PO: oral administration; wk: week. ∗Oseltamivir treatment administered to animals.