Table 1.
Authors | Year | Country | Type of stigma | Sample size | Key points |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Wyke et al. | 1988 | UK | Perceived, enacted | 170 | Most individuals disclosed IBD, most co-workers/employers were understanding, IBD led to changes in work |
Drossman et al. | 1989 | USA | Perceived | 150 | Most common concerns related to surgery, energy level and body image |
Salter | 1990 | USA | Internalised | Not clear | Ostomy allows “to control” the disease, feeling clumsy during sexual intercourse |
Mayberry et al. | 1992 | UK | Enacted | 58 (CD only) | Unemployment, CD patients more likely to conceal their disease to employers |
Moody et al. | 1992 | UK | Enacted | 53 | Employers unwilling to employ an individual with IBD and to give time off to attend clinics |
Mayberry | 1999 | UK | Enacted | 195 (personnel managers) | Unwillingness to provide time to see the physician, IBD jeopardises promotions |
Moody et al. | 1999 | UK | Perceived | 64 | Many students complain of teachers not being sympathetic, underachievement due to ill health |
Moskovitz et al. | 2000 | Canada | Perceived | 86 | Poor social support is related to worse surgical outcomes |
de Rooy et al. | 2001 | Canada | Perceived | 241 | Greater stigma perceived by elderly, females, patients with UC, and with low level of education; |
Levenstein et al. | 2001 | Cross-national | Perceived, internalised | 2002 | Complications and variable disease evolution elicit concern; specific issues vary among countries |
Daniel | 2002 | USA | Perceived, enacted, internalised | 5 | Impaired body image, feeling different, ashamed and worried about others thinking IBD is used for secondary gain |
Krause | 2003 | Chile | Internalised | 19 | IBD as illness that invades all dimensions of life |
Looper and Kirmayer | 2004 | Canada | Perceived | 89 (51 IBD) | Higher level of perceived stigma in functional disorders vs other medical conditions (including IBD) |
Finlay et al. | 2006 | USA | Perceived | 148 | Major differences across ethnic groups regarding knowledge of disease and social support |
Smith et al. | 2007 | USA | Internalised | 195 (71 with IBD) | Disgust related to low colostomy adjustment, low life satisfaction, low quality of life and to stronger feelings of stigmatisation |
Simmons et al. | 2007 | UK | Internalised | 51 | Stoma acceptance, interpersonal relationship and location of the stoma were associated with adjustment |
Taft et al. | 2009 | USA | Perceived | 211 | Perceived stigma affects quality of life |
Voth and Sirois | 2009 | UK | Internalised | 259 | IBD self-blame is related to poorer outcomes |
Taft et al. | 2011 | USA | Perceived | 496 | Greater stigma in IBS than IBD, patient outcomes more affected in stigmatised IBD patients |
Dibley and Norton | 2013 | UK | Perceived | 611 | Emotional and psychological impact, feelings of stigma, limited lives, practical coping mechanisms |
Czuber-Dochan et al. | 2013 | UK | Perceived | 46 | IBD-related fatigue not addressed in medical consultations |
Taft et al. | 2013 | USA | Internalised | 191 | Social isolation common due to stigma |
Czuber-Dochan et al. | 2014 | UK | Enacted | 20 (healthcare professionals) | IBD-related fatigue poorly understood |
Frohlich | 2014 | USA | Perceived | 14 | Feeling stigmatised by partner, healthcare professionals, and colleagues |
Saunders | 2014 | UK | Perceived | 16 | Non-disclosure because of shame may lead to experiencing blame |
Bernhofer et al. | 2017 | USA | Perceived | 16 | Feeling labelled as unable to tolerate pain |
Rohde et al. | 2018 | USA | Enacted | 127 | Enacted stigma among college students decreases when IBD is disclosed |
Gamwell et al. | 2018 | USA | Perceived | 80 | Indirect effect of perceived stigma on depressive symptoms as it impacts on social belongingness |
Dibley et al. | 2019 | UK | Perceived, internalised | 18 | Kinship stigma is present in IBD patients |
CD Crohn’s disease, IBD inflammatory bowel disease, IBS irritable bowel syndrome