Skip to main content
. 2019 Dec 31;15(2):211–223. doi: 10.1007/s11739-019-02268-0

Table 1.

Relevant studies exploring stigmatisation in patients with inflammatory bowel disease

Authors Year Country Type of stigma Sample size Key points
Wyke et al. 1988 UK Perceived, enacted 170 Most individuals disclosed IBD, most co-workers/employers were understanding, IBD led to changes in work
Drossman et al. 1989 USA Perceived 150 Most common concerns related to surgery, energy level and body image
Salter 1990 USA Internalised Not clear Ostomy allows “to control” the disease, feeling clumsy during sexual intercourse
Mayberry et al. 1992 UK Enacted 58 (CD only) Unemployment, CD patients more likely to conceal their disease to employers
Moody et al. 1992 UK Enacted 53 Employers unwilling to employ an individual with IBD and to give time off to attend clinics
Mayberry 1999 UK Enacted 195 (personnel managers) Unwillingness to provide time to see the physician, IBD jeopardises promotions
Moody et al. 1999 UK Perceived 64 Many students complain of teachers not being sympathetic, underachievement due to ill health
Moskovitz et al. 2000 Canada Perceived 86 Poor social support is related to worse surgical outcomes
de Rooy et al. 2001 Canada Perceived 241 Greater stigma perceived by elderly, females, patients with UC, and with low level of education;
Levenstein et al. 2001 Cross-national Perceived, internalised 2002 Complications and variable disease evolution elicit concern; specific issues vary among countries
Daniel 2002 USA Perceived, enacted, internalised 5 Impaired body image, feeling different, ashamed and worried about others thinking IBD is used for secondary gain
Krause 2003 Chile Internalised 19 IBD as illness that invades all dimensions of life
Looper and Kirmayer 2004 Canada Perceived 89 (51 IBD) Higher level of perceived stigma in functional disorders vs other medical conditions (including IBD)
Finlay et al. 2006 USA Perceived 148 Major differences across ethnic groups regarding knowledge of disease and social support
Smith et al. 2007 USA Internalised 195 (71 with IBD) Disgust related to low colostomy adjustment, low life satisfaction, low quality of life and to stronger feelings of stigmatisation
Simmons et al. 2007 UK Internalised 51 Stoma acceptance, interpersonal relationship and location of the stoma were associated with adjustment
Taft et al. 2009 USA Perceived 211 Perceived stigma affects quality of life
Voth and Sirois 2009 UK Internalised 259 IBD self-blame is related to poorer outcomes
Taft et al. 2011 USA Perceived 496 Greater stigma in IBS than IBD, patient outcomes more affected in stigmatised IBD patients
Dibley and Norton 2013 UK Perceived 611 Emotional and psychological impact, feelings of stigma, limited lives, practical coping mechanisms
Czuber-Dochan et al. 2013 UK Perceived 46 IBD-related fatigue not addressed in medical consultations
Taft et al. 2013 USA Internalised 191 Social isolation common due to stigma
Czuber-Dochan et al. 2014 UK Enacted 20 (healthcare professionals) IBD-related fatigue poorly understood
Frohlich 2014 USA Perceived 14 Feeling stigmatised by partner, healthcare professionals, and colleagues
Saunders 2014 UK Perceived 16 Non-disclosure because of shame may lead to experiencing blame
Bernhofer et al. 2017 USA Perceived 16 Feeling labelled as unable to tolerate pain
Rohde et al. 2018 USA Enacted 127 Enacted stigma among college students decreases when IBD is disclosed
Gamwell et al. 2018 USA Perceived 80 Indirect effect of perceived stigma on depressive symptoms as it impacts on social belongingness
Dibley et al. 2019 UK Perceived, internalised 18 Kinship stigma is present in IBD patients

CD Crohn’s disease, IBD inflammatory bowel disease, IBS irritable bowel syndrome