Skip to main content
. 2020 Feb 27;11:132. doi: 10.3389/fphar.2020.00132

Table 1.

Characteristics of the included studies.

First Author (Year) Study Period Sample size (T/C n) TNM Stage Drug Delivery TCM Duration TCM Intervention Paclitaxel Regimen TRR
(T/C n)
Chen (2009) 2005–2007 34/33 IIIb: 23/24; IV: 11/9 Injection 6w Huachansu injection TPF: PTX+PDD+5-FU 15/12
Ge et al. (2014) NR 20/20 Advanced stage Orally 8w Jianpixiaozheng decoction TS: PTX+S-1 10/9
Huang et al. (2018) 2015–2016 50/50 Advanced stage Injection 18w Kanglaite injection + Jianpiyiqi decoction TP: PTX+PDD 35/20
Lai et al. (2018) 2015–2018 30/30 IV Orally 6w Shenlingbaizhu decoction TCF: PTX+CF+5-FU NR
Li N. J., et al (2016) 2013–2014 25/25 Advanced stage Orally 4w Rg3+Shenyi capsule TCF: PTX+CF+5-FU 17/11
Li et al. (2010) 2007–2009 42/40 Advanced stage Orally 22d Liujunzi decoction TCF: PTX+CF+5-FU 25/23
Li et al. (2016a) 2012–2015 33/32 IV Injection 8w Fufangkushen injection + Yiqiyangwei decoction PTX 27/18
Li et al. (2016b) 2014–2015 50/50 Advanced stage Orally 8w Shenlingbaizhu decoction TS: PTX+S-1 27/22
Liao (2018) 2015–2016 31/31 Advanced stage Injection 4w Kang'ai injection PTX+CF 27/19
Liu and Zhang (2009) 2006–2008 30/30 IIIb: 17/14; IV: 13/16 Injection 20d Aidi injection TPF: PTX+PDD+5-FU 16/16
Meng (2019) 2015–2016 50/50 III: 34/36; IV: 16/14 Injection 12w Fufangkushen injection PTX 35/15
Tan et al. (2013) 2007–2011 40/46 IV Orally 6w Fufangbanmao capsule PTX+5-FU+LV 19/12
Xue and Mao (2017) 2013–2015 45/45 Advanced stage Orally 8w Rg3 TCF: PTX+CF+5-FU 35/28
You and Huang (2009) 2007–2008 22/24 III:6/5; IV:16/19 Orally 24w Fuzhenghewei liquid medicament TP: PTX+PDD/TCF: PTX+CF+5-FU 8/8

T, treatment group; C, control group; TNM, cancer staging system; NR, not reported; TCM, traditional Chinese medicine, TRR, tumor response rate; w, week; d, day; PTX, paclitaxel; PDD, cisplatin; 5-FU, 5-fluorouracil; CF, calcium folinate; LV, leucovorin.