Table 2.
Spectrum of approaches to music and trauma.
Musical purpose | Stabilizing | Entrainment | Exploratory | Performative |
---|---|---|---|---|
Music methods | Focused music listening | Group drumming, structured improvisation, shared singing | Music psychotherapy—improvisation, guided imagery, song writing | Song writing and performance |
Neural activity | Primitive | Primitive | Cognitive | Multiple |
Relevant theories | Porges, Perry | Siegel, Ogden | Herman, Van der Kolk | Herman, Butler |
Form | Individual | Group | Individual or Group | Group |
Context | Short-term acute | Community | Long-term recovery | Community |
Therapeutic focus | PTSD symptoms | Dissociation | Integration | Recovery |
Regulatory | Physiological regulation | Co-regulation | Emotion regulation | Self-regulation |
Reported benefits | Reduced negative symptoms, sleep, relaxation | Varied | Emotional work, self-worth | Social connections, resilience |
Research | Quant | Varied | Varied | Participatory/Program description |