Skip to main content
. 2020 Mar 4;2020(3):CD008962. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD008962.pub2

NTR7093.

Trial name or title Needle aspiration of calcific deposits versus extracorporeal shock wave therapy for conservative therapy resistant calcifying tendinitis of the shoulder
Methods Study design: parallel, two‐arm, randomised controlled trial
Setting: Maxima Medical Centre, Netherlands
Interventions: needle aspiration of calcific deposits vs ESWT
Analysis: not reported
Participants Inclusion criteria:
  • aged > 18 years

  • chronic shoulder complaints > 6 months

  • calcifications on conventional X‐rays: type I and II calcifications according to the Gärtner classification; minimal diameter of calcification of 10 mm on anteroposterior view

  • able and willing to comply to study protocol


Exclusion criteria:
  • clinical signs of a frozen shoulder or adhesive capsulitis

  • history of operations of the affected shoulder

  • needle aspiration of calcific deposits or ESWT during last 6 months

  • clinical and radiological signs of acute subacromial bursitis

  • full‐thickness lesion of the rotator cuff tendon(s) on sonography

  • clinical and radiological signs of acromioclavicular osteoarthritis

  • rheumatic arthritis or fibromyalgia

  • other intra‐articular pathology: cartilage lesions, biceps pathology

  • any contraindication for the specific treatments (e.g. coagulopathies, malignancies in treated area

Interventions Needle aspiration of calcific deposits: sonographically guided removal of the calcific deposits will be performed
ESWT: participants will receive a focused ESWT
Both procedures will be conducted according to a standardised protocol
Outcomes Outcomes included in review:
  • recovery of functional outcome score of the Constant Score (baseline to 12 months)

  • pain scores (baseline to 12 months)

  • quality of life scores (baseline to 12 months)

  • medication use and adverse events (12 months)


Outcomes excluded from review:
  • cost‐effectiveness

  • the 'Diagnose & Behandel Combinatie (DBC)' to find a difference in procedural costs of the 2 treatment modalities

Starting date 1 April 2018
Contact information Dr Max Reijman PhD, Maxima Medical Centre, Netherlands
Notes Estimated completion date: 1 January 2021
Trial registration: NTR7093. Status on 8 May 2018, recruitment not yet commenced.