Skip to main content
. 2020 Mar 27;12(3):85–92. doi: 10.4240/wjgs.v12.i3.85

Table 2.

Studies validation and modification of Bolondi criteria

Patients (n) Treatment Median follow-up Ref. B1 B2 B3 B4 Independent risk factor of survival
80 LR, TACE 28.19 mo Ciria et al[9] OS rate: 43.75%; 5-yr survival rate (62.9%) OS rate: 40%; 5-yr survival rate (28.1%) OS rate: 11.25%; 5-yr survival rate (28.1%) OS rate: 5%; 5-yr survival rate (15.1%) Total bilirubin, subclassification stages B2 and B3-4 vs B1
90 TAE NR Scaffaro et al[10] Mean OS: 33.6 mo Mean OS: 28.6 mo Mean OS: 19.0 mo Mean OS: 13.0 mo NR
580 TAE NR Wang et al[12] Median OS: 28.8 mo; 1, 3, 5-yr survival rate: 80%, 39.5%, 21.4% Median OS: 15.6 mo; 1, 3, 5-yr survival rate: 59.2%, 23%, 13.9% Median OS: 6 mo; 1, 3, 5-yr survival rate: 39.5%, 11.2%, 7.4% Median OS: 9.6 mo; 1, 3, 5-yr survival rate: 46.2%, 23.1%, 7.7% AFP level, AST, and substage B2, B3, and B4 vs B1
254 TACE, LR, OLT 15.4 mo Weinmann et al[13] Median OS: 31.9 mo; 1, 2-yr survival rate: 82.93%, 60.98% Median OS: 26.9 mo; 1,2-yr survival rate: 72.9%, 52.44% Median OS: 13.5 mo; 1, 2-yr survival rate: 65%, 40% Median OS: 10.9 mo; 1, 2-yr survival rate: 48.98%, 38.35% Total bilirubin, MELD score, presence of ascites, and the therapies resection and OLT.
269 NR NR Giannini et al[11] Median OS: 25 mo Median OS: 16 mo Median OS: 9 mo Median OS: 5 mo Subclassification of BCLC B, MELD score, and platelet count.
821 TACE NR Kim et al[14] 1, 3, 5-yr survival rate: 95.1%, 66.4%, 41.2% 1, 3, 5-yr survival rate: 78.4%, 33%, 20.3% 1, 3, 5-yr survival rate: 59.3%, 10.5%, 0 1, 3, 5-yr survival rate: 57.4%, 43.7%, 17% NR

LR: Liver resection; OS: Overall survival; TACE: Transcatheter arterial chemoembolization; OLT: Orthotopic liver transplantation; MELD: Model of end-stage liver disease; NR: Not reported.