Skip to main content
. 2003 Jul 21;2003(3):CD000008. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD000008.pub2
Study Reason for exclusion
Ailioaie 1999 No inactive control group
Aillioaie 2000 Not acupuncture
Berger 1975 Non‐randomised controlled trial.
Choudhury 1989 Before and after study of acupuncture in extrinsic asthma
Chow 1983 RCT on induced asthma attacks (not covered by this review)
Eber 2001 RCT on exercise‐induced asthma (not covered by this review)
Fung 1986 RCT on induced asthma attacks (not covered by this review)
Gruber 2002 RCT on induced asthma attacks (not covered by this review)
Jobst 1986 RCT of acupuncture in COPD.
Karst 2002 RCT of acupuncture in healthy participants
Luu 1985 RCT of thoracic trigger points with evaluation of lung function 2hs after treatment
Maa 1997 RCT of acupressure in COPD.
Mehl‐Madrona 2007 No sham control group
Morton 1993 RCT on induced asthma attacks (not covered by this review)
Sovijarvi 1977 Not randomized, short‐term observation
Stockert 2007 Addition of therapy to acupuncture not given to control group
Takishima 1982 Not randomized, short term observation
Tandon 1989 RCT on induced asthma (not covered by this review)
Tashkin 1977 RCT on induced asthma attacks (not covered by this review)
Virsik 1980 Not randomized, short time observation
Yu 1976 Randomization not reported, treatment on an acute attack
Zhang 2006 Methods not sufficient to determine quality