Skip to main content
. 2012 Dec 12;2012(12):CD001894. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD001894.pub5

2. Prognostic factors in included trials.

Study ID Balanced age between groups Balances no. of embryos transferred Prognosis: poor/good FSH levels Blastocyst transfer Complete/partial AH Frozen cycles
Antinori 1999 AH mean 1.5 years older Yes Good and Poor subgroups No data No Complete hole Not stated
Balaban 2006 Yes Yes Unselected < 10 No Thinning Frozen
Balakier 2009 AH mean 1.3 years older Yes Good < 10 No Thinning Fresh
Baruffi 2000 Yes Yes Good No data No Thinning Fresh
Carter 2003 Yes Yes Good < 10 No Not stated Fresh
Ciray 2005 Yes Yes Good < 15 No Thinning Fresh
Cohen 1992 Yes Yes Unstated <= 15, and > 15 subgroups No Complete hole Fresh
Elhelw 2005 Yes No data Poor No data No Thinning Frozen
Fang 2010 Yes Yes Not stated No data No Mechanical expansion Frozen thawed
Ge 2008 Yes Yes Mixed No data No Thinning Fresh and Frozen Subgroups
Germond 2004 Yes Yes Mixed, in subgroups between 3 and 12 No Complete hole Fresh and frozen, in subgroups
Hagemann 2010 Mean age data only given for combined cycles 1 and 2 Yes under 38 years, >2 previous failed cycles, ZP thickness >13micrometers No data No 20micrometer diameter opening Fresh
Hellebaut 1996 Yes Yes Good No data No Complete hole Fresh
Hurst 1998 Yes Yes Good < 10 No Complete hole Fresh
Isik 2000 AH mean 1.4 years older Yes Unstated < 10 Yes Removal complete Fresh
Isiklar 1999 No data Yes Unstated No data Yes Complete hole Fresh
Jelinkova 2002 Yes Yes Poor No data Yes Removal complete Fresh
Kutlu 2010 Yes Yes Good and Poor Subgroups No data No Complete hole Fresh
Laffoon 1999 No data No data Good No data No Complete hole Fresh
Lanzendorf 1998 No Yes Poor No data No Complete hole Fresh
Nagy 1999 Yes Yes Unstated No data No Thinning Frozen‐thaw cycles
Ng 2005 Yes Higher proportion of controls received 3 embryos Unstated < 11 No Thinning Frozen‐thaw cycles
Petersen 2005 Yes Yes Poor No data No Thinning Fresh
Rufas‐Sapir 2004 No data Yes Poor No data No Complete hole Fresh
Ryan 1997 No data No data Unstated No data No Complete hole Both
Sagoskin 2007 Yes Yes Good < 10 No Hole Fresh
Stein 1995 No data No data Poor No data No Complete hole Fresh
Tucker 1993 Yes Yes Good < 15 No Thinning Fresh
Tucker 1996 AH mean 1.8 years older Yes Not stated No data No Complete hole Fresh
Valojerdi 2010 Yes Yes Not stated No data No Partially thinned Vitrified‐warmed embryo

AH = assisted hatching 
 ET = embryo transfer 
 FSH = follicle‐stimulating hormone